Two years ago, when the scandal-plagued William Lantigua was still mayor of Lawrence, then-city councilor Dan Rivera decided to take him on, making a forceful argument: Lantigua was making the city look bad.
“When you can’t get industry to come in here, and can’t get state and federal leaders to take a picture with you, that’s a problem,” Rivera told me in 2013.
The argument worked. After a dramatic recount, Rivera won an 83-vote victory. But now, midway through his term, Rivera is facing a challenge Lantigua confronted four times — a recall effort that could cut his time in office short.
The recall affidavit that outlines the case against Rivera identifies ten separate allegations, including “political retaliation,” neglect of pedestrian safety, and opposition to a new city ordinance that limits cooperation with federal immigration authorities.
But according to Modesto Maldonado, the president of Lawrence’s city council, frustration with Rivera is also a matter of political style.
“I would say that Lantigua was a people’s mayor,” Maldonado said. “He knew everybody; everybody knew him. His doors were always open. People would come in and ask for him and he would see them.”
“Our current mayor, I don’t believe, is a people person,” Maldonado added.
Maldonado also believes that the allegation of “political retaliation” is legitimate.
“Mayor Rivera practically got rid of every employee that was appointed by Mayor Lantigua,” he said. “There are only, I believe, two left.”
Maldonado tells WGBH News he expects those ex-employees to sue the city, and to win. That could cost Lawrence millions of dollars, he claims — and ultimately, that’s why Rivera needs to go.
“Let me put it this way: If the mayor remains this way in the two years he has left, I believe the city is going to go bankrupt,” Maldonado said. “Do I want city bankrupt? No.”
But Rivera has a radically different take on the recall effort, which he says is simply an extension of a very close election.
“We won by 83 votes,” Rivera pointed out. “You know, I think they were collecting signatures for a recall the night we won the recount.”
And that charge of “political retaliation?” Utterly bogus, Rivera insists.
“We actually ran on removing people from office who were unqualified,” he said. “And so that’s what we did, It just happens that the last administration put a lot people who were unqualified into critical positions.”
When the various allegations against him are considered collectively, Rivera argues, there’s simply no coherence.
“It just becomes this laundry list of things, and you get a critical mass of people that are upset about you,” he said. “You make people pay taxes, you hold people accountable for their job, you expect people work at a higher standard — you change the way people do business in the city for a long time, this is expected. It makes people very scared.”
In Lawrence, it takes just 100 signatures to start the recall process. The current recall — which was initiated by William Green, a police officer whom Rivera attempted to fire in 2014 — has been hung up in court thanks to a legal challenge from the mayor.
If it proceeds, recall supporters would have to gather approximately 5,600 signatures in order to force a recall election. None of the four recall pushes aimed at Lantigua, Rivera’s predecessor, reached that point.
Still, whatever happens, the current recall push has already bolstered the stereotype of Lawrence as dysfunctional and borderline ungovernable — a stereotype Rivera insists is wrong.
“This is not crazy Lawrence,” the mayor insisted. “This is a city where basically, resources are scarce, and who gets to sit in the seat of mayor gets to say where some of those resources go, decides where those resources are going to go. So yeah, we’re going to fight about it all time.”
“Lawrence is still open for business,” Rivera added. “And I think we work really hard every day to kind of stay on track, and move the needle on being more professional, and getting work done, applying for grants, making sure kids are being taught well, making sure our police are doing their work and we have safer streets. All that stuff is current, always happening.”
Ultimately, this may be the sole point on which the mayor and the council president agree.
“Lawrence is a wonderful city,” Maldonado says. “Lawrence has so many opportunities that it offers to people, and that’s why so many people come here. People on the outside have always had the wrong perception about Lawrence. Always!”
If so, Lawrence’s tumultuous politics may be one big reason why.