Boston Public Radio continues its ongoing coverage of the four questions on the ballot facing voters this November. Last week, we took on Question 1 on increasing slots parlors in the state. Today, we look at Question 2, which would authorize the approval of up to 12 new charter schools or enrollment expansions in existing charter schools by the state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education per year.
On both sides of the charter school discussion, we were joined by Boston City Councilor Tito Jackson who opposes increasing the number of charter schools, and Paul Grogan, president and CEO of the Boston Foundation. Though neither Grogan nor the Boston Foundation endorse a specific stance on Question 2, Grogan joined to discuss the merits of charters.
Why or why not more charters?
GROGAN: The principle reason is we are in the middle of a great success story in the context of the growth and development of the charter school movement in Massachusetts, and particularly in Boston. Tom Kane, the foremost scholar on charter performance at Harvard, this morning released a new report which synthesizes the many independent studies that have now been done about the impact of charter schools on student achievement and, as has been previously shown, the results are absolutely decisive. Charters are getting astounding results with low-income, minority children. We have a big success heer in one of the most difficult areas of American life. Nationally, this picture is still very grim in terms of how low-income minority kids are doing in urban public school systems. We have a chance to do something fundamentally better. How could we not try to extend that success to a larger and larger group?
JACKSON: The Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation came out with a report where they absolutely didn’t look at the students Paul is talking about. We have more than 100,000 special needs students, and in the Mass. Taxpayers Foundation report they actually don’t look at that. They also don’t look at how charter schools affect local school district budgets. The reason why that’s critical is that Boston Public Schools generally work with a group of young people who have more vulnerabilities and more challenges. Boston has 30% of students who are English language learners. The charters in Boston are about 12%. What that does, financially, to the city of Boston is: we get $215 million from the state of Massachusetts and $160 million of that off the top goes to charters for 8,200 students. In addition, we lose another $15 million for transportation. $175 million off the top. Boston public schools are #1 nationally and fourth in eighth-grade reading scores for large public districts. We’ve been doing really well as a state. 96% of students actually go to district public schools. We are number one in the country. I don’t believe charters can take responsibility for us being number one in doing the work we’re doing. Lastly, this is also about local control. Charters are not controlled locally, and towns and cities like Brockton actually didn’t want a charter, they have no failing schools, and now they are forced to have a charter over the objections of local and elected officials.
To hear more from the discussion, tune in to Boston Public Radio above.