It’s an ethical question investigative journalists and filmmakers often face: if you turn up evidence that sheds new light on an old crime, when and how do you bring it to the attention of authorities? Now, one HBO documentary is under scrutiny for how it may have handled that decision.

With a subject like Robert Durst, there was little doubt “The Jinx” would be compelling. HBO’s six-part documentary follows filmmaker Andrew Jarecki as he looks into how the one-time heir to a real estate fortune became a three-time murder suspect who somehow dodged justice. 

And we hear from Durst himself, including a bombshell saved for the final episode, an apparent confession uttered by Durst after he thinks the interview is over. But there’s another twist: just before the final episode, police arrest Durst for one of those old murders.

Support for GBH is provided by:

Andrew Jarecki recorded Durst’s apparent confession in 2012, leading to the natural question: when did he get that recording, and when did it take it to the police?

Jarecki said he wasn’t aware of what he had until months later. As for when he shared it with police, so far, Jarecki is refusing to be more specific, but he resolutely denies colluding with police to time the arrest just before the finale.