Skip to content
What matters to you.
0:00
0:00
NEXT UP:
 
NEWS_The_Big_Dig_S4-Healthcare_3000x3000_F2.jpg

What Romneycare didn't solve

32:00 |

About The Episode

Romneycare did not solve American healthcare, just as Obamacare did not solve American healthcare. If anything, the issue feels more unsettled, more contentious than it has in a long time. So we round out the season with a pair of conversations looking at those unsolved problems, and the serious work ahead.

Tiffany Joseph is a professor of Sociology and International Affairs at Northeastern University, and the author of the book "Not All In: Race, Immigration, and Healthcare Exclusion in the Age of Obamacare.”

Tiffany: I've been doing research on this issue now for over 15 years, and I get an insurance letter, a letter from my insurance company explaining some recent visit I had, and my eyes still glaze over.

And so the Massachusetts reform expanded access to coverage in a system that already was pretty much broken and very difficult to navigate.

NARRATION: From GBH News, this is The Big Dig. I'm Ian Coss.

So we just finished this whole series about Romneycare, about the crazy backstory of where the ideas came from, about the weird alliances and deals, about the influence it had nationally, the lives it changed.

But I think as we're sitting here in 2026, I don't need to tell you that the work of American healthcare is very much unfinished. Romneycare did not solve American healthcare, just as the Affordable Care Act did not solve American healthcare. If anything, the issue feels more unsettled, more contentious now than it has in a long time. So we're gonna round out the season with a pair of conversations looking at those unsolved problems and the serious work ahead.

Tiffany Joseph is a professor of Sociology and International Affairs at Northeastern University, and the author of the book "Not All In: Race, Immigration, and Healthcare Exclusion in the Age of Obamacare."

On its face, her book is about a small slice of the immigrant population here in Massachusetts that was not served by Romneycare. But in an interesting way, her study of people who are often seen as being at the margins of society, actually has a lot to say about the challenges facing the entire healthcare system today -- meaning: for all of us. So that's where we're headed.

Ian: Tiffany, thank you so much for doing this.

Tiffany: Thank you for the invitation. It's an honor and a privilege to be able to talk with you about the Massachusetts health reform.

Ian: So to set this up, I wanna go back into your research. When did you get interested in this question of access to healthcare? When did you start kind of putting out the feelers of this research?

Tiffany: So for me, oddly enough, it actually started with a previous research project I was doing in Brazil with Brazilians who had migrated to the US and returned back to Brazil. And even though the focus of that project was really about how migrating between Brazil and the US changed the way people think about race, an issue that kept coming up in my interviews with those return migrants was, "When I lived in the US, I couldn't get access to healthcare."

So people would say things like, "I couldn't get sick in the US because I didn't have anywhere else to go for care. I felt like I was not able to properly see physicians if I needed to because the system was very complex." I even interviewed some return migrants who made the return migration to Brazil sooner than anticipated because they developed pretty severe health conditions, and they felt they would have better access to healthcare in Brazil than in the United States. And that was something that really remained with me because I did that research in 2007 to 2008 in a small town in Brazil where most Brazilian immigrants in Greater Boston come from.

And many of those people lived in Massachusetts. And so that was not too long after the reform had been implemented.

Ian: And did you know about Romneycare, this Massachusetts experiment?

Tiffany: At least at that particular time, I didn't, because I was a graduate student finishing up my PhD. And I ended up getting the opportunity to do a postdoctoral fellowship with the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and I got placed at a site, the site at Harvard University.

And this was starting in 2011. And at that time, the Affordable Care Act had just been signed into law. It had not yet been implemented. And I kept thinking about those interviews with those people I did in Brazil, and I thought, "Well, I'm gonna be based at Harvard in Greater Boston, where there's a big Brazilian immigrant population."

All of this national attention is on health reform because Obamacare had just been signed into law. It was based on the Massachusetts health reform, so all of this praise about sort of the reform-

Ian: We solved it. We did it.

Tiffany: So all of this great spotlight on the Massachusetts reform as we're getting ready to move towards ACA implementation. And I just kept thinking about my interviews with those people in Brazil, many of whom had lived in Massachusetts and talked about challenges navigating the system. And I thought-

Ian: And chosen to leave and go back to Brazil just to get healthcare.

Tiffany: Yes, in some cases. And so I thought this might be a really important opportunity to try to understand, with all of the national praise and coverage that the Massachusetts reform is getting, who was left behind potentially?

Ian: So an important distinction between the law in Massachusetts and the federal law, Obamacare, that was based on it, is that here in Massachusetts, non-citizen residents were allowed to purchase individual plans through the exchange. And in some cases, they could get subsidized plans through the exchange. Could you explain a little bit how that worked for people who are here who are not citizens? And at a high level, did they sign up?

Tiffany: So that's a really good question, and the first thing I do wanna mention is that in terms of distinctions between non-citizens and citizens, there are a wide range of documentation statuses that exist, from undocumented all the way up to being what's called a legal permanent resident, what we commonly know as a green card holder.

And due to federal laws, starting in the 1970s, undocumented immigrants were pretty much targeted as being ineligible for most sort of federal social safety net programs. And over time, that exclusion started to expand to certain pockets of documented immigrants as well. So by 1996, there is a big immigration and welfare reform that happens under President Clinton. And basically, this is-

Ian: when you get work requirements for

Tiffany: welfare and things like that. But in terms of immigration, what it did was it implemented a five-year bar, requiring people to have their green card for five years before they were eligible for certain types of public benefits in the United States.

Ian: Over time, there's been kind of a narrowing of who can access the social safety net and increasingly non-citizens being kept out of that.

Tiffany: And so that's really important because at the state level, states can make decisions about whether they will use state funds to provide access or eligibility to some of these immigrant groups that have been excluded at the federal level. And in the case of the Massachusetts health reform, that's what the state of Massachusetts decided to do.

Ian: But it's all on the state. Anything to do with-

Tiffany: Nothing in terms of the federal government. So that's a really important distinction.

Ian: So given everything you've laid out, that Massachusetts did go to this extra length to make the new healthcare reform open to and even subsidized for non-citizens, I wanna go back to that story that started this: you in that small town in Brazil in 2008 meeting folks who were leaving Massachusetts, leaving the place that we might like to think of as the mecca of American healthcare, to go back to their country in Brazil so that they could get better healthcare. How do you square those things? How were those people not getting covered in the new system?

Tiffany: So just in terms of one of the stories from the research I did in Brazil, one of the people that I interviewed talked about developing some pretty severe health issues from having lived and worked in the greater Boston area probably for a couple of decades, and the sort of work that they were doing was very physically strenuous work. House cleaning, the chemicals, all those sorts of things. And these are sorts of jobs that many immigrants end up working in that sort of make it possible for US society to thrive in a way. But the health implications of working really long hours, not sleeping really well, being exposed to chemicals, really started to have some bearing on creating musculoskeletal issues, asthma, respiratory issues.

And eventually this person just sort of felt like, "I'm working really hard here. These health conditions are getting worse. I'm gonna have a challenge getting access to coverage here or figuring out how to even navigate the US healthcare system, so let me just go back home where at least I know how that system works and I at least can get access to some type of coverage and care that also probably won't bankrupt me either."

And so I mention that particular story because, even as I was doing the research, there'd been a number of reports over the years from the Blue Cross Blue Shield Foundation of Massachusetts. Every few years they would have these reports of who were the remaining uninsured, and in that report it would talk about how 98% of the population has been covered.

Ian: We love to tout that stat, the 98%, best in the nation. But there's still the 2%.

Tiffany: That's right, and those reports most of the time would say that the people who were more likely to remain uninsured tended to be Latino, lower income, male, and English was not their primary language of communication.

So the reform was great because it expanded coverage, but the US healthcare system has been very difficult to navigate for most people. Even if English is your first language, if you have basic level education, just trying to figure out what's a deductible, what's in network, what's out of network, I mean,

Ian: I have a PhD and I work as a journalist, and I have trouble navigating it, so.

Tiffany: I've been doing research on this issue now for over 15 years, and I get an insurance letter, a letter from my insurance company explaining some recent visit I had, and my eyes still glaze over.

And so if it's that difficult for people like us, who have high levels of education, English is our primary language, we probably have pretty good healthcare, at least in terms of through our jobs or what have you, just imagine what it's like for people who don't have access to any of that and they're trying to figure out how this system works.

So the Massachusetts reform expanded access to coverage in a system that already was pretty much broken and very difficult to navigate.

Ian: What it makes me think about is, when we cover in the series how the Romney administration, part of the pitch all along that they made to the Bush administration in Washington and to others is, this is a market-based reform. And that's what gets picked up with the ACA too: we're gonna work within the current system. We're not gonna try and tear it down and build something new. We're not gonna try and fight the insurance companies to the death on this. We're gonna work within the market. And what I see in the Massachusetts plan, in Romneycare, is basically the extreme case of how far can we get within that current market system, right? 'Cause it's basically been souped up with a mandate, right? We've legally required and put a penalty in place to make sure that everybody's in the system. We've subsidized the heck out of it. We set up this website. There's this phone line where people can call and sign up. The state really tried a lot of things to get everyone in. And I wonder if that just reveals for you anything about the fundamental limits of how far you can get within what is fundamentally a fragmented system.

Tiffany: Absolutely. So the limits are that the process of applying to coverage was not very easy for people to do. So at the time when I started the research for this book, back in 2012, to apply for coverage there was an application that you could fill out with paper and a pen. So this is, I'm dating myself a little bit here. But I remember I went to the website, I downloaded it, printed it out just so I could see, or try to put myself in the place of someone trying to kind of go through the whole experience.

And the font was really small. I could barely read it. It was asking for proof of state residence, proof of income, and proof of documentation status. And so for particular communities, it might be difficult to produce those things that are a part of the application process. For instance, if you're an undocumented immigrant living in the state, you couldn't get a driver's license. That's one of the ways you can have proof of residence, that you're eligible, that you live in the state. Another way you can do that is if you have-

Ian: So it's like a catch-22. You're eligible for healthcare, but you need a driver's license to prove that you're eligible for healthcare, but you can't get a driver's license. So therefore you're sort of not eligible, or there's this weird chain of things that-

Tiffany: So you have to be able to fill out the application. At that time, it was only available in English, so if you don't speak English or English was not your primary language, if you didn't have someone who could help you figure that out, you were kind of stuck.

If you couldn't provide proof of residence that you lived in the state, either through having a driver's license or, let's say, an electric bill or your name on a lease or a mortgage, for instance. If you're in a shared living situation, because we know that housing in this area is very expensive, oftentimes people have shared living expenses. Their name's not on the lease. If your name isn't on a bill or on a lease, yes, you are contributing to that household, but you don't have any proof that you do live there. So again, that's another way in which people, what scholars refer to as bureaucratic disentitlement. Yes, you're eligible, but these requirements in the application process are ways in which people are singled out of it even though they're eligible.

Proof of income, the same thing. If you're not consistently working or if you're being paid in cash, how do you provide proof of income? Because that's what's used to determine your income level for what eligibility or type of coverage you get sorted into under the Massachusetts reform. So again, those are two sorts of examples of where, yes, everyone can download the form, print it, fill it out, but everyone isn't able to apply for coverage.

Ian: In some ways, that whole Romneycare, Obamacare generation of reforms, they brought all these people in, but they did it by adding more layers of complexity. Now there are more entities, more rules, more programs. And so as we push that system harder and harder to get towards universal coverage, it just gets more convoluted and more expensive and more complicated. And now in a state like Massachusetts, where it's down to that last 1 or 2 or 3% of people who are not covered, it seems like no amount of additional complexity is gonna get you there because the complexity is what is keeping those people from getting coverage or, if they have coverage, keeping them from getting care.

Tiffany: Absolutely. And the other piece that I wanna mention too, just in terms of the population that I was doing research with, immigrant populations, the issue of immigration enforcement, which has only expanded significantly since I started the research 14 years ago, was another big factor too, particularly for these communities that I was doing research with.

So I was interviewing Brazilian, Dominican, and Salvadoran immigrants over the course of the study. Even back in 2012, the issue of enforcement was one that I was hearing about in my research as being a deterrent to people seeking out care. So even if people had coverage, they at times were fearful of going out of their homes to get care because there were ICE raids that were happening even in 2012. Under the Obama administration at that time, there were ICE raids that were happening, and I would hear things like people would say, "Oh, yep, I saw the police at the end of my street. There were raids in my neighborhood the night before. I'm not going to my doctor's office." And I would hear that from providers too who would say there would be certain days where they would be getting lots of phone calls from patients canceling their appointments, saying, "Yep, there were ICE raids," or, "There were rumors of ICE raids, so we're not going anywhere."

And I would say that that's another issue particularly for immigrant communities, and not just for people who are non-citizens, but I also, in my research, I interviewed naturalized citizens who also talked about concerns of, "If I get pulled over because I look like an immigrant, then I'm concerned I'm going to be racially profiled and targeted, and so I'd just rather not deal with the hassle of going to the doctor today if I'm afraid that I see someone, a uniformed officer in the T station or someone walking down the street." And it could just be a security guard, but just seeing someone in some sort of a uniform that seemed like it could be law or immigration enforcement was a big deterrent for people as well.

NARRATION: After the break, those rules and policies that once were focused on immigrants start affecting all of us.

Ian: Are there any people who you interviewed, back in 2011, '13, or even farther, who you've stayed in touch with? How has it played out? Have people kept their coverage, or are there people who have struggled to keep their coverage?

Tiffany: So in terms of the immigrant populations, each year that I did research for the book, I interviewed new immigrant respondents. And I did that because it was recommended that in order to ensure the safety of immigrant respondents to not collect any of their contact information.

But I was able to re-interview some of the advocates and some of the providers. And so in those interviews with those people, and some of them I have stayed in touch with, basically the story that I've heard is the situation has gotten really, really difficult for people to maintain coverage and access to care over time. That was a really, really big piece.

Ian: There's a woman named Dania, whose story you tell in the book. Do you remember some of the details of her story of getting coverage and then what happened afterwards?

Tiffany: Absolutely. So Dania was a middle-aged woman. She was Dominican. I believe she was a naturalized citizen, but basically she talked with me about how her healthcare costs were so expensive that she could no longer afford to keep her coverage. Because of her income level, I don't think she was eligible for any subsidies, and so she was paying out of pocket, and she eventually had to let her coverage lapse because she just couldn't afford it anymore.

And I think that's one of the things about the Massachusetts reform that we've also heard a lot about over the years, that we also have some of the highest healthcare costs in the country. Those premiums go up every year, and it becomes more and more difficult, particularly for people who aren't eligible for subsidies, to be able to continue to afford to pay.

They just thought, "Okay, maybe I'll just forego coverage and I'll just pay the penalty from not having insurance." So I think that's a really big piece that we haven't talked about yet, the affordability piece and how even still, with people having coverage, if people have high deductible plans, then yes, they'll have coverage, but they just won't go see providers because they can't afford the deductibles. They can't afford the co-pays because they're too high.

And so that's the other side of the coin that even legislators in Massachusetts have talked about over the last 20 years, cost containment, that there's still been challenges around that.

Ian: And that's an excellent teaser because we're gonna have an interview with someone else who has a new book out all about healthcare costs. Cause like you said, all the mandates in the world aren't gonna do anything if at the end of the day, the cost is too high and people would rather just pay the tax penalty than get coverage.

Tiffany: And that also just reminds me, too, of one of the other stories or one of the other interviews that I did as well, with an immigrant respondent who talked about how even though she had coverage, she would rather go to the ER whenever she had health issues because she didn't wanna have to pay the copay to see her actual doctor, even though her doctor was in the same healthcare facility as the ER.

And it goes back to the issue of people just not effectively understanding the system and how to navigate it even when they have coverage, and what are the costs associated with that, not only for the individual, but also for the larger healthcare system too.

Ian: So I wanna end by bringing the conversation up to the present. I remember as I was working on the series, a number of people made this observation to me that this year is a kind of inflection point in a long arc of American healthcare, where if you go back decades, the rate of people with insurance has been going up.

If you go back to Medicare and Medicaid in the '60s, and if you look at the Children's Health Insurance Program in the '90s, through Romneycare, Obamacare, there's been this ongoing kinda march towards universal healthcare. And in the last year, we have retreated from that. We are seeing the number of people without insurance going up right now.

And I was just wondering, given all this history we've talked about, what you're watching for right now over the events that have played out in the last year, and what you think it's gonna mean politically for whatever the next round of healthcare reform looks like.

Tiffany: So I'll just start by saying that one of the things that I've been writing about a lot in op-eds over the last year and a half since the book came out is what people refer to or what I prefer to refer to as OB3 rather than the bill name, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, quote unquote, just because of the major implications that it has not just for healthcare, but the broader social safety net system in general.

And one of the things that I've been writing about is how much of what I found in my research in Boston that I write about in "Not All In" is pretty much a precursor to what we are seeing happen now.

And I say that for a few reasons. First, I mentioned earlier in our conversation that the exclusion of people from the social safety net, particularly for immigrants, started in the 1970s with undocumented immigrants, and over time it expanded to include even green card holders.

With the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, I argue that that expansion, that exclusion is now expanding to include citizens. And for so long, one of the big debates among politicians and among scholars was this notion of deservingness, that citizens are deserving, they're eligible for the social safety net because they are citizens.

And what OB3 does is essentially strip many citizens, millions of Americans, from the social safety net. We see that with the Medicaid work requirements, broader Medicaid cuts, the end to the subsidy, SNAP benefits, all of these things are going to affect a large number of citizens. And so that exclusion that started out with a small group in the 1970s has now expanded to reach a much larger part of the population, so that for years people would think, "Well, I'm not an immigrant. I'm not gonna be affected by these changes," and it's like, yes, now many of us will be.

Ian: It's a big swath of the public is waking up to what has been a reality for a long time.

Tiffany: And then also the second piece is that with regard to a number of these changes, too, we're going to be seeing more increased administrative burdens or barriers for people to sign up for and keep coverage.

So with all of these restrictions, the re-enrollment process, if your address is wrong or if you make a mistake, that's enough to get you cut off of coverage. That's what we're seeing happening or moving towards, again, for larger swaths of the population. That is one of the things that I've been paying a lot of close attention to.

The other piece that I wanna mention, too, is that you talked about over the last year, but I think some of us forget that in 2019, under the first Trump administration, there was the ACA repeal and replace effort. That wasn't successful.

And I bring that up because in 2019, under that ACA repeal and replace effort, I was able to speak with some people that worked at the connector at the time, and they were really freaked out because they were just like, "If all of these federal subsidies go away, all of the progress that we've been able to make in Massachusetts around coverage and bringing people into the system goes away," and that's where we are now in 2026. Not with the repeal and replace effort, but with OB3.

And so it's raising a lot of questions about this huge shortfall in federal funding that allowed the state of Massachusetts to bring more people into the system. What's going to happen to those people? And the state is going to have some really tough decisions to make because fiscally, the funds will not be there. So that's where we are at this moment.

Ian: That's a big answer to a big question.

Tiffany: It is, but I mean, that's what I've really been paying close attention to, really trying to understand what, I guess, this dark moment could potentially bring in terms of maybe creating a more robust healthcare system down the line and Massachusetts being a part of that conversation still.

Ian: Well, if I take one thing away from the story of Romneycare and every wave of healthcare reform, is that it takes a crisis, a sufficient buildup of frustration within the system in order for actual change to happen. So I don't know about you, but I'm very curious to see what happens in the next two to three to four years. It kinda feels to me like the big, slow-moving cycle of healthcare reform is coming back around. I say this at the end of the show.

And I love what you said about how what we've seen over the past year is almost a democratizing of the barriers and exclusion that had been existing for a long time.

And so maybe as a last question, I'm wondering, does that in some way give you hope that as more and more people experience the barriers and exclusion and bureaucratic hold-ups, that that will create a broader base of support to try and reform these things? That it won't just be about that small 2% or that ignorable piece of the electorate, that there could be a broader base of support to look seriously at this stuff.

Tiffany: That's what I'm certainly hoping, that to the extent that more and more of the US population is affected by these policy shifts that are coming, that we will realize more of our shared fate in the midst of this and how we really need to band together to demand more of our government and of our healthcare system, given how much we contribute as members of this society, that all of us should be benefiting from that system and not just a privileged few.

Ian: I think we can all agree on that. Thank you so much for doing this. I really appreciate it.

Tiffany: You're welcome. Thank you for the invitation. This was great.

NARRATION: Tiffany Joseph's book is called Not All In: Race, Immigration and Healthcare Exclusion in the Age of Obamacare.

As I mentioned, our next episode will be a look at the unbelievably high cost of American healthcare and why that issue has been politically untouchable, even -- or maybe especially -- in Massachusetts, one of the most progressive states in the country. 

The Big Dig is produced by Isabel Hibbard and myself, Ian Coss. The editorial supervisor is Azita Ghahramani. The artwork is by Bill Miller. Video for this episode by Anny Guerzon and Marta Franco, and the executive producer is Devin Maverick Robins.

And hey, if you're sticking around for the bonus episodes, I really hope that if you haven't already, you take a minute to subscribe to The Big Dig wherever you get your podcasts and leave us a review so that someone else out there might just give us a chance, too.

The Big Dig is a production of GBH News and distributed by PRX. 

Support for GBH is provided by: