Part 6. The Massachusetts Plan
About The Episode
Immediately ‘Romneycare’ becomes the template for national healthcare reform. And while Democrats are focused on replicating the successes of the plan, there are already cracks showing in the coalition that came together to pass it.
Part 6: The Massachusetts Plan
Archival: House will be in order, members, please take their seats.
NARRATION: On April 4th, 2006, Salvatore DiMasi called a final vote on the bill we know today as Romneycare.
This is Sal, the kid from the North End who grew up with no hot water; Sal who had taken Mitt Romney's lean, conservative bill, and started injecting all kinds of liberal ideas into it. Sal the troublemaker, or Sal the champion -- depending on your point of view.
Archival: An act providing for access to affordable, quality, accountable healthcare
NARRATION: This final bill, as you may recall, was the product of a grand bargain between Sal and his counterpart in the Senate, but also between their allies: progressive activists, faith leaders, business leaders, hospitals. This was the bill they all could live with, and it included, crucially, the so called 'employer penalty.' Every company over a certain size had to insure their workers, or pay the state $295 a head. Not 290, not 300, 295.
The bill passed easily that day, with only a few members voting against it.
Archival: The House will be in a brief recess
NARRATION: Over in the Senate, the vote was unanimous. So all indicators were looking good, and the signing ceremony was set for one week later on April 12th.
The question now was: how did Mitt Romney himself feel about this grand bargain he was about to sign into law?
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: The overall bill is, uh, is exactly what we'd hoped for.
NARRATION: Publicly, he was enthusiastic.
Scott Helman: But then behind the scenes, his political team is scrambling frantically to frame this in the right way
NARRATION: Scott Helman covered Mitt Romney for the Boston Globe. It was unusual for a beat reporter to focus on just one person like this, but at that time this person was both our governor and a presidential candidate.
Scott Helman: He wants the credit for the achievement, um, but he does not want to be tagged with the less popular parts of that bill. Specifically the tax on businesses.
Because again, they're thinking ahead to what are primary voters in South Carolina or in Michigan? Or in Iowa are gonna think, you're trying to run as Republican candidate for president and you just signed a bill levying a new tax. Good luck
NARRATION: When reporters asked Romney about the employer penalty, he deflected. When they pressed, he gave vague answers to the effect of: 'well, the bill could be a lot worse...'
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: And so the uncertainty around Romney's true feelings lingered right up until the day of the signing itself: a grand, theatrical affair at historic Faneuil Hall. It was a bill signing, so the bill would get signed, but Romney still had a few options in play. And Christie Hager -- DiMasi's health advisor -- remembers driving over to the hall with the Speaker, and wondering together if this was the moment when the final showdown over the employer penalty would happen.
Sal was anxious for some intel, so he told Christie to make some calls and see what she could find out. They soon learned that Romney was issuing a press release that day. He was making his move. And that move would shatter the delicate compromise that Sal and his allies had been fighting for.
Sal DiMasi: And this is on the way to the ceremony.
NARRATION: This again is Sal DiMasi.
Sal DiMasi: So at that point, I changed my speech.
MUSIC: Theme
NARRATION: From GBH News this is the Big Dig Season 4: Mitt & Ted. I'm Ian Coss.
I'm guessing that if you came into this series knowing one thing about Romneycare, it's that it was the template for Obamacare. It was the template for bipartisan healthcare reform -- in theory at least. But even as this law was being broadcast to the nation as a success story, cracks were starting to show within the coalition that came together to pass it. Cracks that would have consequences.
This is Part 6: The Massachusetts Plan.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Faneuil Hall in Boston has been the site of many historic events over the centuries: Sam Adams calling for revolution, Frederick Douglass calling for abolition. And we can't forget that epic Senate debate between Mitt Romney and Ted Kennedy. But none of those events can quite compare to what happened there on April 12th, 2006 -- at least, in terms of production value.
Bob Travaglini: That was a Hollywood production.
MUSIC: Enter
Vicki Kennedy: It was a movie set.
Christie Hager: Lots of TV cameras.
Jonathan Gruber: Bunting everywhere.
Christie Hager: Blue velvet.
Brian Wheelan: The colonial band with the fife and drums.
Dennis Smith: Revolutionary War uniforms.
Brian Wheelan: Total absurd pomp and circumstance.
NARRATION: Hopefully all those voices sound somewhat familiar. They have all been part of our story, and they were all there that April day for the signing ceremony -- the culmination of it all.
Dennis Smith: The state went all out.
Bob Travaglini: And I think they hit the target.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: Faneuil Hall has a handsome wooden stage, surrounded by white pillars, oil portraits, and marble statues. But in April of 2006, even that was not enough for the occasion.
Archival: Thank you.
NARRATION: So a second, higher stage was erected on top of the regular stage.
Vicki Kennedy: It was like this gigantic thing.
NARRATION: And on top of that second stage was yet another raised platform.
Bob Travaglini: I thought I was gonna get a nosebleed. I was so high up.
NARRATION: On top of that platform was a podium.
Christie Hager: A very high podium.
NARRATION: Standing at the podium, was the man of the hour.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: This is a politician's dream. You gotta admit, standing at the top of this pedestal here…
NARRATION: In some ways, this was the highpoint of Mitt Romney's political career. Never before or since did his prospects seem so great.
Archival: Not just because I'm way up here in the air, uh, but because I look around at the people in this room. What makes it unusual…
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Romney had brought together a truly unthinkable alliance.
All the top Democrats in one of the bluest states in the country, mixed in with folks from the Heritage Foundation and George W. Bush administration -- all slapping each other on the back, and cracking jokes. Romney had a line about how his son told him this bill would also solve climate change, because with all these people working together, clearly hell had frozen over.
Archival: It's now my pleasure to introduce my collaborator and friend, Senator Edward Kennedy. Senator.
NARRATION: Ted Kennedy, who was never one to be outdone on charm, climbed up to that towering podium next and fired right back with his own joke.
Archival: My son said something too. And that is when Kennedy and Romney support a piece of legislation usually one of them hasn't read it.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: This fleeting scene of Mitt and Ted side by side on that stage was a sign of everything that was possible.
Archival: That’s not true today, is it Governor?
NARRATION: A sign of what could be possible for the nation -- if we worked together. And Ted Kennedy used his time up there to make sure everyone watching knew that.
Archival: This is a moment to savor. Of hope and promise and achievement for all the people of our commonwealth, and perhaps for the rest of America too. And we intend to make the most of it. Thank you very much.
Jonathan Gruber: It felt momentous.
Dennis Smith: Absolutely felt historic.
Cindy Gillespie: It belonged to everyone.
Bob Travaglini: It was just something that you knew you were never gonna experience again.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: But that day at Faneuil Hall, while most people were listening to the fife and drum band, or looking over the programs printed on fake parchment paper, or pinning on their buttons that said "Making History in Healthcare," Mitt Romney was quietly preparing to make his last move. At the end of the ceremony, he would use his line-item veto power to strike out several pieces of the bill, including the employer penalty. Sal DiMasi knew this, so he was quietly preparing to make his final stand.
And of all the politicians on that high stage, Sal spoke last.
Archival: Thank you. Thank you very much.
Sal DiMasi: So I got up, and the first thing I said, Governor, I'm going over two minutes.
Archival: Since I'm speaking, I think last, they only gave me two minutes. But Governor, if I go over, I'll gladly pay the $295 assessment fee, contribution tax, whatever you wanna call it, Governor.
NARRATION: Down below on the regular stage, Romney looked up and smiled, then pulled off his wrist watch and held it up to show he was keeping track of time.
Archival: Uh, whatever you're calling it today.
NARRATION: Then Sal got serious.
Archival: Governor Romney, this bill was crafted after long and difficult negotiations. It is the result of compromise and concession among legislative leaders to change anything will disturb the delicate balance that made this law possible.
Sal DiMasi: And then I told him that, that the bill was a delicate balance. If you veto any of it, right, it won't work.
Archival: We today are embarking on a journey through uncharted waters, new innovative ideas, creative ideas to reform healthcare.
Sal DiMasi: So don't veto anything, right?
Archival: I ask all of you to join with me in making this healthcare reform bill a successful journey. Thank you.
Sal DiMasi: And he vetoed it anyway.
MUSIC: Transition
NARRATION: Once the speeches were done, Romney moved to a wooden desk placed at the front of the stage, in the center of a round Persian rug. And there, with cameras clicking away, he used fourteen different pens to sign the bill into law. All except for the eight sections he vetoed.
The whole production was over in less than an hour. Sal DiMasi left the stage with the veto paperwork in his suit coat pocket. He paused to show the papers to one of his close allies, who responded: "Are you shitting me?"
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Governor Mitt Romney indicated a number of vetoes, including one that charges businesses $295 per employee that they refuse to insure.
I don't think it's necessary. I think in some ways it could be counterproductive. So you know, I'll send that back.
NARRATION: Now it turned out the vetoes were ultimately symbolic. Sal and Trav quickly convened their two chambers, and overrode the Governor. But here's what's really important:
With that symbolic veto, Romney claimed for himself just a faint sliver of distance -- plausible deniability if need be. The law may be known by his name, it may carry his signature, but from the very beginning it was not entirely his. It was more generous, more expensive, more expansive than Romney would have liked. And that sliver of distance would of course grow, to a gap, to an arm's length, and eventually to an awkward, unbridgeable, and yet unerasable void.
Romney's staffer Brian Wheelan could see it coming almost right away.
Brian Wheelan: It wasn't too long after we passed the bill that he began to realize that healthcare reform in Massachusetts was not helpful to him, right? And he started to moonwalk away from it.
NARRATION: But we're getting ahead of ourselves. In 2006 Romneycare was a triumph for everyone involved -- including for Mitt Romney and his staff. And I want to linger in that feeling for a moment.
Tim Murphy: Cindy came up to me after the bill got passed and, and she's like, we've gotta celebrate.
NARRATION: That night after the signing, Tim Murphy of the Romney Mod Squad, put together a party -- with some encouragement from Cindy Gillespie, the advisor who had come with Mitt from the Olympics.
Tim Murphy: And I said, uh, okay. We should do this at Lucky's Lounge. And of course, Cindy not from here, she had no idea what it is. And I said, oh, this is a great place.
NARRATION: So he got his staff to book the room, line everything up, and around 5 p.m. that night, Tim, Brian, Amy -- all the governor's health staffers -- filed down the steps of Lucky's Lounge. This was a place they knew well. It's where they would go after a tough day at the statehouse.
The Governor arrived last, along with his state police detail. The staties also knew Lucky's. Romney, did not.
Tim Murphy: He was like, this can't be the place. And they're like, oh, Governor, this is the place. Governor was like,, I was really nervous coming in here. I was like, what's going on? You know, 'cause it's like you go down the stairs and it's dark and there's no sign.
Brian Wheelan: And it was one of the funniest events of ever.
NARRATION: Again, Brian Wheelan.
MUSIC: Enter
Brian Wheelan: Governor's giving his speech down in the bar—he doesn't drink, he's not a fun guy. We're down in the basement of a bar at Lucky's. People are lighting it up. The Governor's like, hey, you guys are at my local dig.
Tim Murphy: He goes, that table back there, that's Ann and my table. Like, we come here all the time.
Brian Wheelan: Ann and I come here all the time. It was so absolutely funny.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: For Brian, Tim, Amy, Cindy -- the countless other staff who had worked on this bill, this day was the highlight of their professional lives. That's part of the reason I love interviewing staffers. Mitt Romney did a lot of things in his career, Ted Kennedy did a lot of things. For people like Tim and Brian, this was the thing. The chance of a lifetime; the dream. Many of them were not even healthcare people when this all started, but they became healthcare people. Cindy Gillespie went on to run the Arkansas Department of Human Services. Brian Wheelan now runs a network of mental health clinics. Tim Murphy runs a company that provides therapeutic services for children, and is married to a fellow health staffer from the Romney administration. This experience changed their lives.
But even as they drank cheap beers and gave toasts with their stone sober Governor, those same staffers also knew the dream was coming to an end.
Archival: Serving as your governor is one of the greatest honors of my life.
Tim Murphy: One of my biggest professional disappointments in life was that the governor decided not to run for another term for governor.
Archival: I will not be a candidate for re-election.
Tim Murphy: ‘Cause we passed that bill in April of 2006, and he was out by January, 2007. And, you know, ultimately that was Mitt’s decision.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Well, Governor, here we are ... congratulations. It's pretty exciting. Thank you. Pretty exciting. Thank you very much.
NARRATION: On January 3rd, 2007, less than a year after the bill signing, Romney offered a handshake to his successor, Democrat Deval Patrick, and turned to leave the governor's office for good.
Archival: And I guess we get to head back that way. No, wait, no, no, no, no, no. Oh, I, I almost- I have to have the key ... I almost, that's ex- I almost left you without the key to the door. Here, this is, uh, this is yours.
NARRATION: The same day, he created a committee exploring a run for president.
At that time, the new healthcare exchange wasn't even open to most people. The individual mandate was not in effect. The rollout for Romney's signature achievement had barely begun.
The reason this was so disappointing for Romney's staff, and maybe history altering for the rest of us, is that a lot of important choices about the law got made after they were gone.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: The final text of Romneycare is pretty short for something this important, about sixty pages. It was deliberately vague on questions like: What health insurance are we actually mandating people to get? What exactly does it need to cover?
Romney's original vision of Romneycare was to require only very basic insurance -- something to cover you in the event of an emergency. Romney's pitch was always about personal responsibility -- take care of yourself, don't be a freeloader. It was not about some lofty idea of healthcare as a human right.
And I think this gets missed in a lot of framings of the Romneycare story. Because as much as Romney did move away from his own law, the law also moved away from him, or away from his original vision anyway. It became more expensive, more comprehensive, more generous -- inching closer to a Ted Kennedy vision of universal healthcare. That is why Tim Murphy regrets to this day that they didn't get the chance to truly do Romneycare Romney's way. Because he saw just how influential that law became.
Tim Murphy: And I think the arc of healthcare and health insurance would be very different if he had run for another term of office, than what it is today. You know, just a missed opportunity.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Follow me. When it comes to choosing health insurance plans, you need an expert guide. Let the Health Connector help you find your way. This way.
NARRATION: In May of 2007, the Mass Health Connector opened for business.
Archival: Quality plans.
NARRATION: This is what the Heritage Foundation folks had called the 'exchange,' and the Obama folks would ultimately call the 'marketplace.' But the legislature here decided to put their own spin on it -- something a little less businessey...
Archival: A message from the Health Connector and the state of Massachusetts.
NARRATION: The Massachusetts experiment was now officially underway.
Archival: Just call 1-877-MA-ENROLL.
NARRATION: There were ads on TV and radio reminding people to sign up. The Red Sox started running announcements during games at Fenway Park. Pastors talked about the new law from the pulpit. A local non-profit run by John McDonough started its own help line for people trying to get coverage; they fielded 39,000 calls that year. This was the power of having a thousand fathers behind the reform -- they all wanted it to succeed.
Archival: Remember, sign up by November 15th to avoid paying tax penalties. A message from the Massachusetts Health Connector.
NARRATION: Pretty quickly, the number of new sign-ups topped four hundred thousand people -- the vast majority of the state's uninsured population was now insured.
Archival: My name is Keith Rudolph, and I am a leader with the Roxbury Presbyterian Church.
NARRATION: Among them, was Keith Rudolph, better known as Rudy.
Archival: I'm here tonight with my wife and my four-year-old son.
NARRATION: The man who had struggled to get coverage for his family -- including a young child with autism -- who had gone door to door gathering signatures with his pastor for the effort. Here he is speaking in 2008.
Archival: Several months ago, I was enrolled into Commonwealth Care and having health insurance has made peace of mind a part of my vocabulary.
NARRATION: For Rudy, getting insured was just a first step towards getting access to programs and services for his son, Elijah. It made all the difference.
Keith Rudolph: And let me tell you, God is my witness. He didn't speak till he was almost five, but once he started talking, oh my God. It was like, "Elijah, come on. It's time to go to bed, baby." "Daddy, Daddy, blah, blah, blah. Mommy, Mommy, blah, blah, blah" Oh my God. But it was music to my ears. But it was because of the access to doors that were closed due to lack of insurance that we were able to experience what we're experiencing now. My son took me to dinner Sunday. My autistic child took me to dinner Sunday. Okay? That's bringing tears to my eyes now when at one point we couldn't get him to eat his own food. You know what I mean? It's, it's... that's, that's, that, that, that, that, Sorry. That, that's an impact. That, that's an impact. I'm sorry. Yeah.
Ian Coss: What kind of food you get?
Keith Rudolph: Oh, okay, I told you I'm a Southern man. I raised my boy Southern. There is the only Golden Corral in the state of Massachusetts is out in Springfield. Pi-
Ian Coss: made the pilgrimage.
Keith Rudolph: Picked him up from work, and we jumped in the Tundra and off we went. So yep. And my baby boy, my 22-year-old autistic child said, "Y'all don't worry about it. I got you." And he bought us dinner. Yep, he did.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: The insured rate for the state eventually rose to over 98%-- by far the best in the nation. Meanwhile the number of employers who offered insurance also rose, proving that businesses were in fact doing their part to get people covered. And the number of people seeking free care at the emergency room went down, just as everyone had hoped. In the simplest terms of expanding access to insurance, the law was undeniably doing that.
Pretty soon, Massachusetts became exactly what Ted Kennedy had hoped: a model for the nation.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Many of the people I interviewed remember being swept up in a kind of unofficial Romneycare press tour. Legislators, bureaucrats, academics -- really anyone who had touched the bill could climb on board and help spread the word.
Amy Lischko: You know, after it passed, everybody was out on the speaking tours. I did more of the academic kinds,
NARRATION: Amy Lischko, you may remember was the real policy expert of the Mod Squad -- she called herself the grandma of the group. And while she was happy to go out and talk about the Massachusetts plan, she was also uneasy about it.
Amy Lischko: I didn't present it like it's an answer for the country. When I would get asked that question, you would talk about, yeah, pieces of it could work for other states, but I wasn't really thinking about it as a national reform.
NARRATION: Part of the anxiety was just the fact that healthcare in different states is very different. And the issues around it are very different.
Cindy Gillespie: You know, I'm from Georgia, right? Rural Georgia.
NARRATION: Cindy Gillespie -- who was the outsider of that Romney team -- knew this better than anyone.
Cindy Gillespie: You know, I know people who have to drive hours and hours and stay overnight in order to go get their chemo. It's, no, it's a whole different thing. Solving for healthcare in the areas where you don't have healthcare resources is another thing. It's like there it may not be that the solution a state comes up with is to give everybody insurance.
Ian Coss: So you wanted to see more of like a 50 state solution?
Cindy Gillespie: Something where each state found its own way.
NARRATION: At first, it seemed like this kind of state by state process might just work.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: There was interest in Connecticut, Minnesota, New York, California. Utah was interested. Indiana was interested. Someone in the Bush administration said that the Health and Human Services Department heard from half the states in the country -- all hoping to replicate some aspect of what Massachusetts had done. It might not be the whole bill, but states could pick and choose the elements that worked for them.
Jonathan Gruber: So they started asking for my help.
NARRATION: Jonathan Gruber is the MIT economist who advised the Romney administration, and he was eager to jump on the Romneycare roadshow, and help other states do the same thing.
Jonathan Gruber: I worked with Oregon, I worked with Kansas. And In particular the highlight was I worked closely with the state of California.
NARRATION: And California became a key testing ground: could another state replicate the magic?
MUSIC: Out
Jonathan Gruber: This is the highlight because I'm a kid of the ‘80s. So Schwarzenegger movies were my currency.
NARRATION: In January of 2007, so right when Romney was leaving office, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger of California launched his own reform effort based around an individual mandate.
Jonathan Gruber: So I got to go meet Schwartzenegger. And in fact, before you meet him, outside his office, he had the sword from Conan the Barbarian. I got to hold the sword from Conan the Barbarian, which is probably the highlight of my entire time working on this. And you go to meet him and I've never met anyone looking so uncomfortable in a suit, you know? And he's really, he's just such a bulky guy. He is like, we would get health insurance for everyone in California. It really was like talking to the action hero. But he was very smart and he really sort of understood the issues and said, this plan makes sense. Let's just do it.
NARRATION: On paper, California seemed like an obvious next step. Like Massachusetts, a very progressive state, run by a moderate Republican governor who like Romney was willing to be the champion.
Jonathan Gruber: I worked very hard on this for about a year. And then the price tag came out for my modeling. And the price tag was like 3 billion for California.
NARRATION: But then there were all the factors that made Massachusetts unique -- the low uninsured rate, the reforms that had already been done, and most of all, that billion dollars of federal money that Romney and Kennedy had managed to save with their tag team lobbying effort. California did not have that kind of money.
Jonathan Gruber: They didn't have this pot of money. They could just rededicate like Massachusetts did. They had to do that by raising new taxes.
MUSIC: Enter
Jonathan Gruber: And it was like the second that number came out, it was like you could hear a pin drop and it all just collapsed.
NARRATION: The same story played out in other states. The model was not actually a model anyone else could follow.
Jonathan Gruber: So what I realized and state leaders realized was Massachusetts was a one-off. States didn't have the resources to do this. If it was gonna be done, it had to be done at the federal level.
NARRATION: And of course, what else was happening in 2007, in those very same months when the law first took effect: the opening salvos of the presidential race -- the most wide-open, unpredictable race in a generation. Healthcare would be at the center of it.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: The first shot of the epic 2008 Democratic primary healthcare battle, was not fired by Barack Obama, or by Hillary Clinton. It was fired by John Edwards, the Senator from North Carolina.
Archival: I will not compromise on universal healthcare, not on coverage, not on quality, not on cost.
Jonathan Gruber: Edwards immediately came out and endorsed the Massachusetts plan.
NARRATION: MIT economist Jonathan Gruber advised the Edwards campaign, and later the Clinton campaign as well. Remember, the Romneycare halo was at its absolute brightest at this point. So Gruber was in high demand.
Jonathan Gruber: Edwards said, I'm gonna do the Massachusetts plan very early. And Hillary Clinton's campaign realized, well, we can't be outflanked to the left on healthcare coverage.
Archival: I think it's tremendous that we have unanimity here.
Jonathan Gruber: We've gotta say we support universal coverage and the Massachusetts plan is getting universal coverage, so we gotta support it too.
NARRATION: Julie Rovner, the reporter, covered this whole back and forth for NPR.
Archival: Well basically she’s done frankly what they’ve done in Massachusetts…
NARRATION: As Edwards then Clinton embraced the Massachusetts plan, including crucially: the individual mandate.
Jonathan Gruber: They did, Obama did not.
MUSIC: Enter
Julie Rovner: Obama sensed correctly that this was gonna be difficult, um, politically difficult. He was right.
NARRATION: Obama did release his own more modest plan with no mandate, but he got hammered pretty hard on it -- by the competition, and by the press.
Julie Rovner: Because he really didn't have a handle on the issue the way Hillary Clinton did at that point.
Archival: The only difference between Senator Clinton's healthcare plan and mine is that she thinks the problem for people without healthcare is that nobody has mandated, forced them to get healthcare.
Julie Rovner: I remember thinking, oh, I don't know that he's really ready for prime time on this.
Archival: There's a big difference between Senator Obama and me. He starts- All right. Well, uh... from the premise of not reaching universal healthcare. One at a time.
NARRATION: Some analysis showed that Obama's plan would leave up to 15 million Americans still without insurance. In other words: it would not solve the problem. Ezra Klein, who was then writing for The American Prospect, said the plan suffered from, quote: "a lack of audacity."
It was the same basic trap that Romney had been in a few years earlier. The politics of the mandate felt perilous, but all the data said you cannot get to universal coverage without it.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: I'm Mitt Romney. I believe in America, and I'm running for president of the United States.
NARRATION: Of course, Mitt Romney himself was at the same time attempting to run his own primary race, for the opposite party. And he was in a trap too.
Scott Helman: There was no space in the center.
NARRATION: Scott Helman again covered Romney for the Boston Globe, and he later co-authored a biography called "The Real Romney."
Scott Helman: There was no space for a moderate technocratic governor who was liberal on social issues. That was not a lane that was open because of John McCain and Rudy Giuliani, who at the time was seen as a very viable, sort of center right candidate for president.
NARRATION: McCain and Giuliani were far more established at this point, with bigger national profiles and clogging up that center lane.
Scott Helman: And so Romney and his team looking at the field thought, well, our only real shot here is to go way right. That's where the opening is.
MUSIC: Enter
Scott Helman: Thus began this clear right rightward shift.
Archival: The way in the GOP presidential sweepstakes is clearly to the right.
NARRATION: We covered the beginnings of this shift a couple episodes back -- how Romney started taking harder positions on issues like abortion, gay marriage, even stem cell research. How he would travel to Iowa or South Carolina and joke that being a conservative in Massachusetts was like being a cattle rancher at a vegetarian convention.
But all that only increased once he was officially running.
Scott Helman: And I think that, I think this healthcare issue very neatly captures the contradictions of Mitt Romney.
MUSIC: Out
Scott Helman: I remember him going in front of the CPAC audience, right, which is kind of a rite of passage.
NARRATION: Early in the campaign, Mitt made a critical appearance at CPAC, the Conservative Political Action Conference -- the place to address the right wing of the party. Helman, as the Globe's full-time Romney chaser, was there.
Scott Helman: And probably of all the events that he was doing, this was one where he had to get the message right, and frame all of these decisions he'd made in Massachusetts and bills he’d signed and whatever else in a way that would be a really appealing to them.
NARRATION: The event was in a grand hotel ballroom lit by chandeliers. The stage was flanked by nine American flags on each side. In the center was Mitt Romney.
Scott Helman: Putting his own state, kind of in the cross hairs a little bit
Archival: It is a great feeling to be with so many conservatives. In fact in honor of the occasion I invited all of the Massachusetts conservatives to come hear me today and I’m glad to report that they’re both here.
NARRATION: Romney seemed to relish talking about his home state on the campaign trail.
Archival: Ronald Reagan said this…
NARRATION: He would wax poetic about Ronald Reagan's vision for a conservative future, but add: "Coming from Massachusetts, I saw the liberal future first hand, and it doesn't work."
Archival: It doesn't work.
NARRATION: Then Romney could talk about cutting taxes while he was governor, cutting spending, cutting government jobs. He could talk about the hundreds of vetoes he sent to the state legislature. He could even talk about losing to Ted Kennedy back in ‘94, and how he may not have won that race, but at least he made Teddy take out a mortgage on his house in order to hold that seat.
Scott Helman: Because the Kennedys are an obvious foil for that kind of crowd, right?
NARRATION: But of course, Romney did also like to reference his landmark healthcare bill, which he signed alongside Kennedy, and by most accounts was now working pretty well.
Scott Helman: It was a big achievement. It was a big thing. It showed he could get something done. He was the CEO governor. Like, it was part of his brand and that's what made it complicated.
NARRATION: As Helman recalls, Romney navigated this awkward reality with a bit of a joke, which I've seen referenced at other campaign events as well. He would introduce the health bill, then add: "I was a little concerned at the signing ceremony when Ted Kennedy showed up."
Scott Helman: And everyone laughed at that, but I just remember thinking it's so odd because you've been working with Ted Kennedy for months and months. Your people have been working with his people to get this done. And it just, as a journalist, when you're covering these things and you're in both places, it felt very jarring. I remember just being like, are you kidding me?
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Helman said it's kind of like when you follow a band on tour, you start to see how they work the crowd in every city. How they make that crowd feel special, how they tweak the stories and jokes to land in that place.
Scott Helman: And I think the journalists who knew him and were following him were the ones who saw all these different versions, and it also just felt very clear what he was doing.
It was kind of like you're looking outside and being like, look, it's nighttime outside. And it's like, but I see the sunlight. You know, what are you talking about? And I just remember thinking, finding it very bizarre that they would pretend like it sort of didn't happen.
NARRATION: The CPAC event ended with a straw poll of who this conservative crowd favored as their champion. John McCain came in third place. Rudy Giuliani came in second. Mitt Romney was the top pick.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Meanwhile Mitt Romney is now attacking John McCain as the liberal in the race… He’s known for some things which frankly are not conservative, Republican…
NARRATION: In many ways, all of Romney's careful positioning ultimately backfired, especially when they were pitted against John McCain, and his 'Straight Talk Express.'
Archival: One thing I think we should really give Governor Romney credit for, he is consistent. He's consistently taken both sides of any major issue.
NARRATION: At one point in the campaign, a man in a grey dolphin costume began tailing Romney at his public events, introducing himself as 'Flipper.'
Scott Helman: I mean, this has always been the thing with Romney, right? Like, who is the real Romney? And the answer is like all of it, right?
Archival: I entered this race because I love America, and because I love America, I feel I have to now stand aside.
NARRATION: By February of 2008, Romney's race was done. But on the Democratic side the race was just heating up, and Romneycare remained at the center of it.
Ian Coss: How ugly did that fight get?
Julie Rovner: It got pretty ugly.
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: One at a time. Now, I understand. But, but look, I'm not- Senator, Senator Obama- We're gonna have a lot more on healthcare. There's no difference- But go ahead. Go ahead. I will be, I will be very brief on this issue. Hillary…
NARRATION: Even after the race narrowed to just Obama and Clinton -- the young Senator from Illinois refused to embrace the Massachusetts Plan.
Jonathan Gruber: And indeed, so much so that he, even during the Iowa caucus, even handed out flyers saying how terrible the individual mandate was.
NARRATION: The Obama mailers read: "Hillary Clinton's healthcare plan forces everyone to buy insurance, even if you can't afford it." It sounded a lot like the Harry and Louise ads back in the 90s -- clearly playing on fear. When an aide handed Clinton one of these mailers, she immediately called a press conference and said: "Since when do Democrats attack one another on universal healthcare?"
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: What's crazy to remember is that at the same moment this heated 2008 race is playing out, the very first real world test of the individual mandate was playing out too, in real time. Again, Amy Lischko:
Amy Lischko: It wasn't even really fully in swing before they were talking about it in DC as a model for the nation. But it quickly became that, like probably too quickly, right?
NARRATION: And what Lischko found most disturbing, was that as the law became more famous nationally, locally it became harder and harder to talk about the problems with it -- because there were problems. For example, she felt that a lot of small businesses were struggling to provide coverage that was generous enough to satisfy the mandate. And that smaller hospitals were struggling to balance their books. In fact, if you look at longer term data in Massachusetts, the number of people seeking free care at hospitals dropped after the reform, but then started to rise again. Some other research shows that immigrants -- especially the undocumented -- had a harder time accessing care in the new system than the old one. So real, practical issues that the nation could learn from.
Amy Lischko: I felt like people were being squashed a little bit from talking about it. Like you couldn't talk about any potential problems that were happening here.
NARRATION: Amy remembers that the board for the new Health Connector would have regular meetings to vote on policy, and the votes would always be strangely harmonious. But that was just because the real debates were happening in advance, one on one, in private.
Amy Lischko: Then everybody would come like to the meeting all like, yeah, this is great. The best thing. Like no dissent at all. And I thought that was kind of not very transparent. I think I would've preferred for everybody to see those struggles and what the discussions were like cause that made it seem like, and I don't know, like there weren't, these weren't complex discussions.
Ian Coss: Mm-hmm.
Amy Lischko: And they are.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Something I've been trying to emphasize throughout this series is that Romneycare was way more contested and contentious than most people on the outside ever realized. Everything about it, from the policy design to the signing ceremony was extremely delicate -- cracked and crooked -- even if the cracks didn't always show.
Amy Lischko: So I think that that maybe came as a surprise to people at a national level when, when people weren't agreeing with us, but actually, like, we weren't even all agreeing and like, it could be a whole table of Democrats and they would disagree on things.
MUSIC: Shift
NARRATION: And those cracks among Democrats would only become more dramatic as the Massachusetts plan shifted from the state level, to the federal level.
If you think about Romneycare from a progressive standpoint, the law left a lot to be desired. It had not made quality healthcare a right to every resident. It had not changed the way hospitals bill for their services, or how drug companies price their drugs. It certainly had not changed the fact that the whole system is run by private insurance companies who have a basic incentive to try and deny people care.
And part of the role Ted Kennedy played in Massachusetts was holding the Democratic coalition together – from progressives to moderates – and making the case to all of them that this bill was better than nothing – that, as he would say, half a loaf is better than nothing.
Now in 2008, as the primary was playing out, it was becoming clear he would have to do that again at the national level: to hold the party together, just a little bit longer. What Kennedy didn’t realize, was that he personally, was running out of time.
MUSIC: Out
David Bowen: As background, all senators have offices in the various Senate office buildings. Some also have what are known as hideaways, which are offices within the Capitol itself.
NARRATION: In 2008, David Bowen was the health policy director for Senator Ted Kennedy.
David Bowen: And like so many things in the Senate, choice of hideaway is determined by seniority. So Senator Kennedy had one of the absolute choice hideaways.
NARRATION: And it was in this hideaway, that the two of them first discussed the bill that we know today as the ACA – Obamacare. The hideaway itself had a window looking west across the whole length of the Capital Mall. It had a handsome fireplace that according to lore at least, was used by British troops to light the torches that burned down the White House during the War of 1812. Among the Senator's staff, that particular story was known as an "Irish Truth", so no need to fact check that one. But Kennedy treated his hideaway like a little museum; filling it with personal mementos: a table made from the rudder of an old family sailboat, a portrait of his eldest brother.
David Bowen: So a really personal space. And we were there, in May of 2008, we had just finished work on a number of bills. And we had some free time.
NARRATION: On this particular day, Kennedy, Bowen, and a few others were supposed to meet with a pharmaceutical executive, but the executive was running late. So instead, they started bouncing ideas of what their next healthcare bill would look like.
In a way, this was nothing special. Kennedy had been introducing healthcare bills for decades -- through the George W. Bush years, the Clinton years, all the way back to Nixon in 1970. It was a congressional ritual at this point: a new session, a new call for universal healthcare. Most of these bills were symbolic efforts, but the Senator sensed that this time could be different.
David Bowen: Senator Kennedy had a view, which I think is absolutely right, of, you have windows of opportunity for particular things.
NARRATION: By 2008 there were almost 50 million Americans without health insurance. 50 million people. And that number continued to rise. Kennedy could feel the pressure for reform growing. The chemistry, as he liked to put it, was right.
David Bowen: And he said to me, I remember quite, quite emphatically more than once, I want my bill ready to go on day one. By which it was quite clear that when Congress reconvened with the new president, whoever that president was going to be, he wanted his bill to be in on day one. And I'm looking at you, Dave, uh, to make sure that that is the case.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: With that, the brief moment of free time expired, and everyone went on with their day.
David Bowen: So I just thought this would be the first of many, many conversations we would have in the same sort of vein, and as events transpired, it was really the last of its kind.
MUSIC: Post
Vicki Kennedy: It started off like any other day.
NARRATION: A few days later, Ted and his wife Vicki woke up at the Kennedy house on Cape Cod.
Vicki Kennedy: Sailboat had just gone in the water and he was looking forward to the first sail of the season. We went downstairs on that Saturday morning, had coffee and he was going out to walk the dogs. I said, okay, sounds great. And he never made it out of the house.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Tonight, Senator Edward Kennedy remains a patient at Mass General Hospital. His condition has not been disclosed. The 76-year-old senator has undergone a series of tests…
Vicki Kennedy: He had what we came to realize was a massive seizure
NARRATION: But that seizure was just a symptom of something much more serious.
Archival: Shortly after 1:30 this afternoon, the Associated Press reported that Senator Edward Kennedy was suffering from a malignant brain tumor.
NARRATION: An aggressive form of brain cancer. Not the kind that stays still, the kind that spreads.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: For decades, Kennedy had told the story of walking the cancer ward where his son was being treated, meeting the families of the other children there, and feeling the awful indignity that some children got treated, and some did not. Now Ted was the one fighting for his life, while also trying to hold on to the fight of his life: universal healthcare.
Michael Myers: One thing I'll never forget is that on his way to his surgery, he called me.
NARRATION: If David Bowen got the policy pep talk, Michael Myers -- the Senator's staff director -- got the strategy talk.
Michael Myers: And he basically gave me the outline over the phone on his way to surgery of how we were to accomplish Obamacare.
NARRATION: Kennedy remembered how in the 1970s he and Nixon had come to the table with wildly different visions for reform; how in the 1990s even the Democrats had come to the table with different visions. How they had lost precious time because they started so far apart. How they waged bitter fights within their own party. This time we need to do better.
Michael Myers: He said, make sure there's one bill.
NARRATION: Find the middle, find the consensus, unite the factions.
Michael Myers: And his final point was, this is gonna be hard, so just be ready, be prepared. This is gonna be hard.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: On the morning of June 2nd, 2008 Ted Kennedy went in for surgery at Duke Medical Center. It lasted three and a half hours, and he was awake for most of it to make sure that his verbal and cognitive abilities were not affected. Around 2pm, the surgeon at Duke announced that Kennedy was out and recovering. But the surgery was no cure; it was a way to buy him some time -- time he needed. Maybe one more year.
Archival: This final morning of the Democratic primary season began with one more super delegate declaring for Barack Obama.
NARRATION: The very next day, June 3rd, was the final round of primary elections for that year. And it was the day that finally determined a winner on the Democratic side. But in a way it didn't matter who the Democratic nominee was. Kennedy was already on the march.
Archival: For me, this is a season of hope.
NARRATION: That summer of 2008, he was looking ahead, beyond November, to January and the next Congress. That was part of the lesson of the Clinton health battle: don’t wait for the president. Be ready.
David Bowen: And the instruction that was ringing in my ears was: I want my bill ready to go on day one.
Archival: The work begins anew. The hope rises again. And the dream lives on!
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: And Kennedy wasn’t the only one getting a bill ready for the new Congress.
Liz Fowler: I think there was a lot of enthusiasm.
NARRATION: Liz Fowler was the health staffer for another powerful senator: Democrat Max Baucus of Montana, chair of the all important Finance Committee.
Liz Fowler: And what struck me is that there was so much consensus around what Democrats wanted to see in terms of reform. It all resembles the Massachusetts proposal.
NARRATION: And here we can see the true significance of Romneycare at work. Now I'm sure some listeners might think I've really gone overboard on the Massachusetts lens I've applied to the story, even for this admittedly Mass-centric show. But I truly think you should not underestimate the power of a simple, memorable, concrete example. I know this as a storyteller. People don't remember policy names, they don't remember peoples' names, they certainly don't remember dates and statistics. We remember characters, vivid images, emotional moments. That is what Romneycare provided: the image of Ted looking proudly over Mitt's shoulder as the governor signs the bill into law. The two of them laughing, clapping each other on the back. It made the issue simple in a way it had never been before. Not in 1974, not in 1994, not in 2004.
Liz Fowler: Fast-forward to 2008, and everyone is pretty much on the same page, and I think that was because it got the support of both Senator Kennedy and Governor Romney. And so I think that became the blueprint.
NARRATION: And for what it's worth, Liz Fowler is from Kansas, her boss was from Montana -- so a little less biased than me.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: John McCain rallied his supporters in Miami, Florida today, where polls say he needs to make up some ground. And Barack Obama was…
NARRATION: That fall of 2008, as the election played out, Liz Fowler drafted up a white paper showing how the Massachusetts plan could be adapted into a national plan. There were some differences of course working at the federal level, but the three legged stool was all there, including notably: the individual mandate. No one knew it at the time, but this paper being passed around quietly among the Senators and their staff was the first draft of the Affordable Care Act. It was titled simply, "Call To Action."
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: In October of 2008, so right around this same time, Mitt Romney made a visit to his old office in the Massachusetts State House. He was just citizen Mitt now, not even a candidate, but he had one last duty from his old job: sitting for his official governor's portrait.
With the afternoon autumn sun beaming in through the windows, Romney took a seat at his old desk. He didn't sit behind the desk, mind you, he wanted to be out in front. Casually, one foot on the floor, like he had just been leafing through some briefing documents, then someone walked in the door and he looked up.
The artist remembered later that Romney was very clear about what he wanted in the painting -- how he wanted to be remembered. There would be an image of Mitt's wife Ann placed on the desk. And right in front of that picture, there would be a thick folder. You have to look carefully to make it out in the final portrait, but the cover of that folder is embossed with a golden symbol of two serpents wrapped around a staff -- the symbol of medicine. It hangs in the state house to this day.
MUSIC: Out
Cindy Gillespie: So take a look at that because I mean, it really comes across that he's very, very proud of having done Massachusetts healthcare reform.
Ian Coss: So at the time, did you think Democrats were misguided in seizing on Romneycare as a one size fits all model for the nation?
Cindy Gillespie: Yes. No two ways about it.
NARRATION: A few weeks after Mitt Romney posed for his Governor's portrait, Barack Obama was elected the 44th President of the United States. The Massachusetts Plan was about to get a new name. And a very new image.
This time there would be party line votes and razor thin margins. There would be rowdy meetings and angry protesters, talk of ‘death panels’ and socialism. If the Romneycare consensus was already fraying, it was about to collapse.
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: I don't want this country turning into Russia, turning into a socialized country. My question for you is: What are you going to do to restore this country back to what our founders created according to the Constitution?
NARRATION: That's next time.
The Big Dig is produced by Isabel Hibbard and myself, Ian Coss. It’s edited by Lacy Roberts. The editorial supervisor is Azita Ghahramani with support from Ryan Alderman. And the Executive Producer is Devin Maverick Robins.
Based on what you’ve heard so far, if you think other people should hear this story, go ahead and leave us a review wherever you are listening right now. Believe it or not, it does help, and I do read them!
A special thank you to Hannah Frigand and the whole team at Health Care For All, who showed me their healthcare hotline set-up, which still runs to this day. And let me also take this opportunity to shout out the Boston Globe. It would be so much harder to tell these stories if we didn’t have that robust local newspaper with a fully digitized and searchable archive. Truly, it’s an amazing resource. Support your local paper.
The artwork is by Bill Miller. Our closing song is “Things Will Be Different,” by The Shods. The Big Dig is a production of GBH News and distributed by PRX.