Part 5. A Thousand Fathers
About The Episode
Time is running out for Massachusetts to pass healthcare reform. The bill’s fate now rests with the two old friends who run the state legislature and control everything that happens there. Unfortunately, these old friends have stopped talking.
Part 5: A Thousand Fathers
NARRATION: At the end of the last episode, things were looking pretty good for healthcare reform. It was the summer of 2005. Governor Mitt Romney was a rising star, already a serious contender to be the next president. And he was using his clout to push for universal healthcare. There was energy in the air -- innovation, optimism that Massachusetts would be the first in the nation to pull it off. But in 2005, for anyone who had been around state politics long enough, there was mixed in with the optimism, a sinking feeling of deja vu: all of this had happened once before. And it had not ended well.
The year was 1988. The rising star governor was Michael Dukakis.
Archival: His fellow governors voted him the most effective governor in America. The son of Greek immigrants.
NARRATION: Heading into that 1988 presidential campaign, Dukakis, like Romney, knew that his case to voters was built on his record as governor.
Archival: …he wiped out huge budget deficits…
NARRATION: His steady leadership, the strong local economy, jobs.
Archival: …and led an economic turnaround they call a miracle…
NARRATION: But it sure would be nice to cap all that off with a signature piece of legislation -- something memorable, something unprecedented, and something the nation could learn from.
Archival: Mike Dukakis, a president for the '90s.
NARRATION: Something like, universal healthcare.
Archival: Why in one of the greatest and most prosperous states in a land of plenty, should people go without decent healthcare?
NARRATION: So now all the Governor had to do was wage a nationwide presidential campaign, and also solve one of the most intractable problems in American society. At the same time.
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: Last week, Dukakis announced his plan to provide health coverage to the state’s uninsured.
NARRATION: The centerpiece of the new Dukakis plan was something called an 'employer mandate'. Basically, the government would force employers to provide healthcare for all their workers.
Archival: Instead employers would be required to purchase coverage for all employees.
NARRATION: This should all sound familiar from our very first episode. It's basically what Nixon proposed in 1974. But you're gonna have to do a little rearranging to your mental map of health policy. Because in 1974, remember, the employer mandate was the middle of the road compromise option that Ted Kennedy reluctantly agreed to. By 1988, everyone has shifted to the right, including Kennedy. His old pitch of 'Medicare-for-all' is feeling politically unrealistic at this point, and Nixon's employer mandate is now the thing that Democrats like Kennedy have rallied around. So from here on, when you hear "employer mandate", think: that's a Democrat idea, a progressive idea, even. And here in Massachusetts, Mike Dukakis was going to actually do it.
Archival: …would require all employers to offer insurance starting in January 1989.
MUSIC: Out
Emily Sherwood: On the one hand it was great that he was shooting for something so big.
NARRATION: In 1988, Emily Sherwood worked as a staffer in the State House.
Emily Sherwood: But even at the time it was being pushed in the context of the presidential race. And you could feel it, right? And so there's just that combination of excitement, but also, get in line.
NARRATION: Meaning: if you were a Democrat, and a team player, then you’d better get behind this bill.
Emily Sherwood: That can be enough pressure to bring someone on board. But it masks deeper discomfort.
NARRATION: And that discomfort would not stay hidden for long. A backlash was coming...
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: Governor Dukakis' bill to provide healthcare for all in Massachusetts is on its way to the House of Representatives now.
NARRATION: In the early months of 1988, just as Dukakis was out barnstorming Iowa and New Hampshire, his health bill moved quickly through the state legislature.
Archival: All those in favor, “Aye”.
NARRATION: Very quickly for something this complex, and potentially disruptive.
John McDonough: So we began to push.
NARRATION: You might recall John McDonough as the guy who helped explain the technical details of Medicaid waivers back in episode 3. He's kind of a health policy lifer who will return a few times in our story. But in the ‘80s, McDonough was in the state legislature, and pushing for this bill alongside Dukakis.
John McDonough: And immediately there was a strong counter reaction
Archival: Today the attack was joined by the people who say they'll bear the brunt of the cost.
NARRATION: A key thing to understand about the employer mandate was that it tried to do two things at once. On the one hand it pressured businesses to provide insurance to their workers directly, meaning you get some people covered that way; but then for any businesses that don't comply, you impose what's called a payroll tax.
Archival: …based on a five percent payroll tax on businesses…
NARRATION: That means the employer mandate is actually generating meaningful revenue that can help subsidize insurance for anyone who doesn't get it through their job -- that's how you get to universal coverage. For people on the left, that payroll tax was an essential feature; for people on the right it was unacceptable.
Archival: Opponents of the governor's bill say it will hurt small businesses like local fast food franchises.
NARRATION: And by February and March of 1988, opposition to the bill was impossible to ignore.
John McDonough: Business community heavily opposed to it.
NARRATION: Insurance companies also had issues with the bill. Hospitals had issues with the bill.
Archival: The hospital industry is up in arms over the plan…
John McDonough: Other players landed on all different sides
NARRATION: The coalition was looking shaky -- especially around the employer mandate. But despite all those warning signs, the bill kept moving.
John McDonough: It got through the house in the spring of ‘88 by only a handful of votes.
NARRATION: And in April of 1988, the same week he picked up key primary wins in New York and Pennsylvania, The Duke got his signing ceremony on the steps of the State House.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: For a moment there, it looked like everything the governor had dreamed of...
Archival: The doubters said that we couldn't do it!
NARRATION: There were orange and yellow balloons with the words 'Health Care For All'.
Archival: That the promise of healthcare for all could never be realized.
NARRATION: Children up on shoulders, straining for a look at history.
Archival: After all, they said, it's never been done before, and for good reason.
NARRATION: Dukakis, at the absolute peak.
Archival: The doubters said a lot of things, and you proved them wrong.
John McDonough: And lots of people were saying, you know, this is all just for show.
Archival: The deed is done.
And so with the stroke of a pen, healthcare for all becomes the law of the Commonwealth.
NARRATION: Of course, after the pinnacle, came the fall. Dukakis lost his election that year, badly. At the same time, the state fell into a recession. Deficits rose. Unemployment rose. I talked to Dukakis about this period for our first season, and in his special understated way, he told me that was, quote: "not a happy time."
Once the distorting gravitational effect of the presidential race was gone, hesitant supporters of the new health law began to defect. Opponents began to speak up louder. The legislature tried to calm everyone's nerves by delaying the deadline for the employer mandate, then delaying it once again. Until ultimately, even staunch believers in the bill found themselves admitting, they had lost.
Again, John McDonough.
John McDonough: And I got up on the floor and I said, as the Chairman of Healthcare, I said, listen, we know this is a problem. People are concerned about it. We are looking at the whole system. And I agreed with deep reluctance to repeal the employer mandate.
Emily Sherwood: It's sort of like things just fall apart.
MUSIC: Theme
NARRATION: So ended the state's first attempt to be the first in the nation on universal health insurance. For progressives like Emily Sherwood and John McDonough, it was a tough retreat on a cause they believed in to the core.
And so in 2005, when Mitt Romney began his own march toward history, and a new doorway for reform appeared, longtime advocates like Emily and John were ready to get involved. They had been ready, been preparing in fact. This time, they would go in with eyes open, knowing the full power of the business lobby, and the danger of crossing them. But that didn't mean they were about to roll over and accept some half-baked free market plan created by the Heritage Foundation and a bunch of MBA consultants. No. Progressives in and around the State House were going to make a stand. They were going to write their own bill, one that looked and smelled an awful lot like 1988.
Emily Sherwood: And I think that was on everybody's mind. It was like, this is what blew it up the last time. Tread carefully.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: From GBH News this is the Big Dig Season 4: Mitt and Ted, I'm Ian Coss.
It only takes a slim majority to pass a bill and change law. But what the Dukakis failure reveals is that to truly change a system as complex as healthcare, you need more than a slim majority of votes. You need a coalition. You need buy-in. You need people who want the new law to succeed. And building that kind of coalition would not be easy.
This is Part 5: A Thousand Fathers.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: One of the many things I love about state politics, at least in Massachusetts, is that a lot of the action happens in one building. The governor's office, the state Senate, the House of Representatives, the treasurer, the auditor, the secretary of state -- they are all physically located under the golden dome of the State House.
The building itself is kind of a sprawling complex at this point. It's been added onto several times over the centuries. And while it still has a lot of grandeur to it, the place is also a bit shabby. Like even in the most powerful, coveted offices of our state government, I have seen paint peeling from the ceiling, mouse traps set along the baseboard, and usually an old AC unit sagging out of the window. This is where it all happens.
And I want you to hold that image through this episode. Even as we shift our attention away from the governor's office and over to the legislature, and even as we meet the various powerbrokers who will wrangle healthcare reform into reality, remember that these people are not isolated in their own castles, shuttling around in motorcades. They're more like hallmates in a college dorm; a grand but kind of shabby college dorm. They are intimately close.
Ian Coss: So, um, could you tell me how you grew up?
Sal DiMasi: Oh my God. Um…
NARRATION: There are really two legislative leaders who we're going to follow closely. The first is named Salvatore DiMasi. Everyone calls him Sal.
Sal DiMasi: We had a cold water flat, and there was no central heat. There was a bathroom in the hallway, and it was shared by the other tenants. And a lot of people grew up that way.
Ian Coss: Yeah, how common was that at the time?
Sal DiMasi: Everyone I knew lived the same way in the North End.
MUSIC: Enter
Archival: How would you describe this to someone who's never been here? It's a festive place.
NARRATION: We did a whole episode about the North End back in Season 2; if you've listened, this is where the Angiulo Brothers ran the city's biggest numbers racket, at least until the FBI busted them.
Archival: My shop? [person speaking Italian]
NARRATION: But to conjure the scene a bit: it's dense, it's brick, very Italian, and back when Sal was young, it was quite poor.
Sal DiMasi: I had to walk every day to the bathhouse.
NARRATION: And because his apartment had no hot water, every day Sal would take a bar of soap, hike down three flights of stairs, and then walk two blocks to the public bathhouse just so he could take a shower. Again this was the norm for those tenement apartments, so Sal would see everyone at the bathhouse -- catching up, gossiping -- the neighborhood was connected at this most human level.
Sal DiMasi: That's the way I grew up. When someone was out of work, we brought them food, and when they were sick, we took care of them. When they didn't have money to pay the rent, we helped chip in to pay the rent. Growing up in the North End, we helped each other.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Sal DiMasi carried that ethos into his politics. And by 2005, the kid from the North End who grew up with no hot water, had risen to become one of the three most powerful people in state government: the Speaker of the House.
Bob Travaglini: It's overwhelming.
NARRATION: Joining him in that very small club was the President of the State Senate, the other legislator we’re going to follow: Robert Travaglini. Everyone calls him Trav.
Bob Travaglini: And being one of the big three where every Monday you met with the governor, the speaker and yourself, it was powerful. You had real power
NARRATION: But really, it was Sal and Trav who had the most power. Because as you may know, Massachusetts has this funny habit of electing Republican governors, but very few Republican legislators. That means Romney could propose whatever he wanted; he could dream up the most elegant, optimized, muffin top of a bill, but he had very little power to turn that bill into law. That would be Sal and Trav's job. And what's interesting, is that in this story where I keep playing up the unlikely, odd couple relationships, Trav and Sal are not that at all; they are a study in similarity.
Sal DiMasi: Trav and I come from the same kind of background.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Trav came from East Boston, just across the harbor from where Sal grew up, but their legislative districts actually overlapped in the North End. Which is pretty weird if you think about it -- that in a state-wide legislature representing hundreds of cities and towns, the two most powerful people represented the same exact place. One man was literally a constituent of the other.
Bob Travaglini: There was no competition because he was in the House or I was in the Senate. I mean, that never came into play.
NARRATION: So Sal and Trav would run into each other at the big Italian saint festivals. Their wives were friends, so the four of them had a regular dinner, often at a place called Saraceno's; where they never even looked at a menu, the food just appeared. Both men were huggers, back-slappers, storytellers, deal makers.
Bob Travaglini: For the most part we worked cooperatively more often than in confrontation with each other.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Now maybe you can see already how this could go. Sal and Trav get together at Saraceno's over a bottle of red and some veal scallopini. The two paisans work out whatever kind of healthcare bill they want, with whatever mandates and taxes they like. They pass that bill with their Democratic supermajorities. And Mitt Romney, he can just take it on that perfect sculpted chin of his. Because that's life as a Republican governor in Massachusetts. You are irrelevant.
Except that's not at all what happened. Instead that smooth relationship between Sal and Trav is about to hit a snag, and the battle lines are about to get scrambled. We'll start with Trav.
Ian Coss: So of the three players you were proposing the more incremental approach, correct?
Bob Travaglini: Correct. No doubt about it.
NARRATION: In the beginning, Trav was actually the most conservative when it came to healthcare.
Bob Travaglini: Ours was in a more incremental, more market based you know, in phases, let's see if one thing works, then we can go to the next one.
NARRATION: He remembered what happened with the Dukakis bill -- how they went big, fast and then the whole thing collapsed. So Trav's basic thinking was: let's do the bare minimum just to keep those safety net hospitals afloat, to keep that federal money flowing; we'll see what works, then we can think about stuff like mandates and universal coverage.
Bob Travaglini: But let's not start off with a car that isn't gonna finish the race. Let's at least get through the first two laps and let's see where we are.
NARRATION: Romney, as you know, wanted to do something more ambitious.
Archival: To provide health insurance to every citizen in Massachusetts, we'll be the first state in America to do that.
NARRATION: He wanted to build that three-legged stool we talked about last episode: with a mandate on individuals to buy insurance, a subsidized exchange, market reforms -- all working together to reach universal coverage. So Romney was in some ways more progressive than Trav on this. But still, the governor's original plan was pretty bare bones in terms of what that universal coverage actually covered. And notably, Romney's plan did not include any kind of tax or mandate on employers. This was all about individuals -- personal responsibility.
Which left the final wildcard: Sal DiMasi. The kid from the North End. He had something more progressive in mind.
Sal DiMasi: And that led to a meeting.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: So one day in the fall of 2005, Sal DiMasi remembers heading down the marble halls of the State House to Romney's office to talk things through.
Sal had been working on his health plan, and he’d landed on an idea he liked to call ‘shared responsibility.’
Christie Hager: This is the fair thing to do. This is shared responsibility.
NARRATION: That’s Sal’s health advisor, Christie Hager. The way she and Sal saw it: employers have a responsibility to provide coverage to their workers. Individuals have a responsibility to make sure they get covered. Everyone chips in, everyone gets by -- just like in the North End.
Christie Hager: There had to be both.
NARRATION: So let’s do both: an individual mandate and an employer mandate.
But in their meeting that day at the State House, it quickly became clear that Mitt Romney did not want anything to do with an employer mandate.
Brian Wheelan: That's Mike Dukakis. That's Hillary Clinton.
NARRATION: This again is Brian Wheelan, part of the healthcare Mod Squad inside the Romney administration. And as he recalls, the employer mandate really was a bright red line; because again, it included the dreaded payroll tax as an enforcement mechanism. I mean, if you think it would be tough selling the individual mandate in a Republican primary, just imagine selling a tax on businesses.
Brian Wheelan: You do that, you're dead. Right? It was that dire.
MUSIC: Out
Sal DiMasi: Romney would not listen to any compromise, right?
NARRATION: So in this meeting, as Sal tells it, Romney kept coming back to his original plan – with only the individual mandate. No employer mandate.
Sal DiMasi: I had my glasses on and I said, "Look into my eye. Does it look like I'm gonna agree to this?” Right? And I took my glasses off, and I said, "Now look deeper into my eye. Do you think I'm ever gonna agree to this?" He got angry, right? And he said, "If we don't have healthcare next year, they're gonna blame you."
NARRATION: Sal immediately fired back: “That's fine, governor." Because I only have to explain my choices to my neighbors right here in the North End of Boston, the people who have known me my whole life, and trust me.
Sal DiMasi: “You'll have to explain it to the United States of America why Massachusetts doesn't have any healthcare, and you're running for President of the United States." I walked out.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Sal announced his own more progressive health bill on October 31st, 2005. Halloween.
Archival: Let's say you had 37 employees. How does this work?
NARRATION: And right away, attention focused in on the twin mandates. Remember, no state had ever tried either of these mandates, let alone both at once.
Archival: Partly the responsibilities of the employer. Partly it's your employees. Is it practical?
NARRATION: But the most intense attention came from the business community -- the people who would be forced to start providing insurance to their workers, or pay a tax. Just like in 1988, they quickly mobilized a lobbying campaign to fight back.
MUSIC: Shift
Archival: Mr. Speaker, I am one of those employers, and for over 44 years, my family has run a small business, as many of you know. We are eight employees…
NARRATION: Within days of introducing the plan, Sal had a revolt on his hands in his own chamber, from his own members.
Archival: This bill is going to kill the goose that lays the golden egg.
Emily Sherwood: The thing to remember is every state rep, they've got a bazillion people they know in their district who run small to medium sized businesses.
NARRATION: Emily Sherwood who we heard at the very top was a health staffer in 1988, still a health staffer in 2005.
Emily Sherwood: And, you know, it's a very real thing to hear from people who are saying, Look, my margins aren't that good. This is gonna really hurt me. You know, whatever. It's not a minor issue.
Archival: I simply propose changing the word Commonwealth Care Contribution and replacing them with the words jobs tax. Thank you, Mr. Speaker…
NARRATION: Sal made some quick moves to try and ease his members' concerns -- tweaks to how the tax would be applied and who would be exempted -- to try and shield small businesses in particular. But no amount of tweaks could erase the fundamental question of responsibility. Should employers be on the hook for healthcare? Was that the right place in our society to put this burden?
Archival: Again, the chair would kindly ask members to subdue their conversation, pay due attention to the gentleman
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Now we have to always keep in mind that the stakes for passing some kind of health bill were extremely high. The state had negotiated to keep that special pot of federal money if and only if they found a new way to use the money, instead of just giving it out to hospitals. Meaning: No health reform bill, no money.
Brian Wheelan: The governor would've lost the money.
NARRATION: According to Brian Wheelan, Romney was prepared to walk away at this point and wash his hands of the whole thing if the bill included an employer mandate and payroll tax. He could even have gone back to the Bush administration and said: you know what, keep the money. We're done here. It very easily could have come to that. Except...on this issue at least, Romney had an ally, someone much more powerful than himself: which of course is the Senate President, Travaglini.
Bob Travaglini: I'm not in the business of putting small businesses outta business.
NARRATION: Trav also did not like the idea of a new tax on businesses.
Bob Travaglini: And a lot of them came to us and said, this is trouble. And we thought that that made sense.
Ian Coss: Why do you think you and DiMasi saw that issue so differently?
Bob Travaglini: Well because it was the House mandate, it was something that gave ownership to the House. Romney had to come in with something and Sal had to come in with something. And that's how it works. I didn't create the system. That system's been in place since the Egyptians, since the Roman times! Everybody has their peace and their price.
Ian Coss: So you think it was ultimately more about pride of authorship than about ideological commitment?
Bob Travaglini: Yeah I think it was both. I mean, Sal believed in what he was doing. He made it clear to us that if that wasn't in the bill, then he was gonna have a problem moving the bill forward.
Ian Coss: And DiMasi he just wouldn't budge at first.
Bob Travaglini: At first he wouldn't budge.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: I've heard many accounts of the Sal and Trav dynamic. In some versions, Trav is simply a puppet for the business lobby and unwilling to think big, while Sal is the true visionary, the true champion of the people. In other versions, Trav is the pragmatic one working towards a real solution while Sal is lost in a fantasy -- stubborn, unrealistic, grandstanding for attention. I imagine there are elements of truth in each. But in every version, the two paisans from Boston had very different views on the employer mandate. A stand-off was brewing...
But outside the walls of the State House, other factions were starting to mobilize around this same issue. So if Trav had the Governor and business lobby on his side, Sal would get some back-up of his own.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Last episode we met one of the state's 500,000 uninsured residents at the time, named Keith Rudolph, the man everyone knows as Rudy. He had been uninsured for years, but the urgency of his situation changed quite suddenly in 2005, because of his son Elijah.
Keith Rudolph: Most kids two, two and a half years old, they're trying to form some type of sentences. He wasn't forming any type of sentences. We couldn't get him to go to the bathroom. We'd always know when he had to go because he'd get quiet and he'd go in a closet or in a corner or something, he could not look you square in the eyes, like I'm looking at you right now. He couldn't do it. He'd always look away or he'd do this, or he'd start making this noise and we're like, "Okay, something's not right."
NARRATION: That year, a relative asked Rudy and his wife: have you had him tested for autism?
Keith Rudolph: And we were like, "Huh? Not our child." You know parents. You know, not my baby. You know what I mean? Oh, that'll never happen to my baby. Well, guess what? It was our child.
NARRATION: Rudy, as you may recall, worked for a small employment agency. He made $30,000 a year. To buy into his company's insurance plan would have cost almost $5,000 a year. To buy individual insurance on his own would be even worse. So he just made do with no insurance.
After he recovered from that stroke he told us about last episode, Rudy had changed up his diet. He became a 'salad man' in his words. He started walking to work to get exercise. He did everything he could do to control his own health. But now there was Elijah, something he could not control. Elijah needed specialists, he needed services, he needed care.
Then one day in 2005, the same year, an opportunity opened up: a way to get that care -- and not just for Elijah.
Keith Rudolph: My pastor knew my situation because a lot of times we'd have to-- I'd have to go to the church for help and that's how I got into it. Reverend Hamilton came to get me. He's like: Listen, here's what I need to know if you can do for me.
NARRATION: Reverend Hamilton, who we'll meet in a bit, had a special way of both asking you to do something, and telling you to do something. Rudy calls it "tasking."
Keith Rudolph: That's telling you and asking you at the same time. So…
NARRATION: And the Reverend had a task for Rudy.
Keith Rudolph: “We're doing this thing," he said. "We got a big group. We need men to come out because women always do all the work. You're gonna come, you're gonna drive my car." And I'm like, "Wait, I thought you were asking me." He's like, "I am asking you, but we'll talk about it in the car. Basically, we gonna do this, and we're gonna knock on some doors, and we're gonna stand out here. And we're gonna do this, and we're gonna get some..." And I'm like, "What is all this for?" "Oh, we're trying to get free healthcare for everybody in Massachusetts." I said, "Really?" I was dressed when he pulled up in front of the house.
NARRATION: Once Rudy knew the purpose of the task, he did not need to be asked or told.
MUSIC: Fade in
Keith Rudolph: I'm thinking about my child Elijah, Elijah, Elijah. You know what I mean? That's what kicked in.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: So the reason Rudy was out knocking on doors, is that his pastor Hurmon Hamilton was part of a whole group of local faith leaders who had teamed up with our old friend John McDonough.
Hurmon Hamilton: John McDonough, is the person who approached us.
NARRATION: McDonough, remember, is kind of a healthcare lifer, he’s been on this issue forever. But in 2005 he saw that a doorway for reform was cracking open.
Hurmon Hamilton: In his words, the stars were aligned.
NARRATION: And when the opening came, McDonough wanted to make sure that progressive voices were at the table – that it wasn’t just the business groups and hospitals and insurance companies running the show.
So he drafted a ballot measure, to put the issue directly before voters. So, what exactly would this ballot initiative call for?
John McDonough: We knew that the individual mandate was a Republican idea.
NARRATION: Definitely not an individual mandate.
John McDonough: We thought, well, most people can't afford to buy health insurance. And so we continued to promote an employer mandate.
NARRATION: Make companies pay for it, that's how they’d get true comprehensive healthcare that someone like Rudy and his son Elijah could actually afford. It was the same logic that led Sal DiMasi to back the employer mandate.
John McDonough: And that's what we moved to put on the ballot.
NARRATION: But John and his allies went even farther than Sal. They created the initiative as almost a provocation, with taxes and regulations that they knew conservatives in the state would absolutely hate. Their goal was simply to apply pressure at this point. As John McDonough put it to me: state legislators now had two guns to their heads. There was the imminent loss of all that federal money to the hospitals, and now there was the looming threat of this ballot initiative, which would take the issue out of their hands altogether.
John McDonough: Two guns aimed right at the head of the state healthcare system. So it was propitious…
Ian Coss: To say the least.
John McDonough: To say the least.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: Over the course of 2005, they gathered more than 100,000 signatures -- way more than they needed to put their proposal on the ballot for the next year.
Keith Rudolph: There were people who wanted to know when it was gonna start before they even signed. You know, they got the pen, but then, “When is it gonna start? Does this mean I'm signing up for it?”
“No, you're not signing up for it. This is a petition so that we can get it to a point where you can sign up for it.”
“Oh, I'm all in for that!”
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: So hopefully you can see now the battle lines that are emerging around the employer mandate in particular -- and they are not partisan.
John McDonough: It was Romney and Travaglini on one side, DiMasi and our army on the other side.
Hurmon Hamilton: And that meant that Mr. DiMasi and others brought us in the room, particularly Mr. DiMasi to say, what can we do here?
NARRATION: This again is Pastor Hurmon Hamilton, the tasker. As he recalls, the message from Sal came in November 2005, right as the fury around the employer mandate was building. Clearly Sal needed allies, and so the ask was simple: join me -- drop your ballot initiative, and back my bill instead.
Hurmon Hamilton: And we said, we are only gonna do that if you're gonna agree to be our champion. And the only way to do that is he had to show up.
MUSIC: Shift
NARRATION: Show up meant, show up in church. Hamilton and the other faith leaders didn't want a promise made in a wood-paneled room at the State House, they wanted a promise made from the pulpit.
Hurmon Hamilton: He said, “Sure, I'll show up. Tell me when and where.” I remember that. “Tell me when and where I'll show up.”
NARRATION: So a few weeks later, on December 1st, Sal showed up, at the African Methodist Episcopal Church.
MUSIC: Fade out
Archival: We're building the serve—we're gonna ask everybody to stand…
NARRATION: Sal's district, as I've said, was focused on the North End -- that dense, heavily Italian pocket right in the heart of the city.
Archival: God Almighty, you’ve been wonderful to me…
NARRATION: This church was about five miles and a world away from his district, in the southern end of Boston: Black Boston -- Dominican, Haitian, Cape Verdean Boston.
Archival: Let's give God the praise. Let's give God the praise. Let's give God the praise.
NARRATION: And the Reverend at the AME church is actually someone we've met before, but in a very different context. It was Ray Hammond -- the doctor who did his residency at Boston City Hospital because he could learn to do everything. Well fast forward to 2005 and the doctor has become a preacher. This is him:
Archival: Hallelujah. Hallelujah. Lord, to you we consecrate these pledges, these commitments that your people have made.
Ray Hammond: And actually it was at our prior campus, which was a gym.
NARRATION: Back then, the AME congregation met in a school gymnasium.
Ray Hammond: Wonderful wooden floor with backboards at either end.
NARRATION: That is where Sal would get to make his pitch.
Hurmon Hamilton: We packed that church.
NARRATION: Again, Pastor Hamilton, the leader of the faith group.
Hurmon Hamilton: And he had never been to a meeting like that, I promise you never been to a meeting like that.
Archival: Lord, Hallelujah. By my spirit. Say it’s the Lord, say it’s the Lord.
NARRATION: The event began with music, then a series of church members came up to share their own healthcare stories -- people like Rudy Rudolph, with no insurance, trying to care for their families.
Hurmon Hamilton: He had to sit and listen to that. It was our meeting. And you need to make a commitment to those people that you are our champion.
NARRATION: Finally, Sal got his chance to speak. He stepped up on a temporary stage over the basketball court and raised both his hands before the packed house. Then he said: "I’m inspired tonight. I feel like saying...hallelujah!"
Hurmon Hamilton: I remember that!
NARRATION: The crowd shouted right back at him: hallelujah!
Hurmon Hamilton: We would say it in our faith tradition filled with the spirit.
NARRATION: And now came the serious part. The faith leaders specifically asked Sal to commit that he would not bend to the business lobby. That he would not sign a bill without some kind of mandate on employers to do their part and provide insurance.
Hurmon Hamilton: And not negotiate away the heart of the bill.
NARRATION: Pastor Hamilton asked Sal, quote "to pledge to us, and to the people of the Commonwealth...that you will continue to stand firm."
Hurmon Hamilton: And he said, “Yes. I will be your champion.”
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: That meant for Sal: no employer mandate, no bill. It was the first time he had made that pledge in public, and drawn that line.
Sal DiMasi: I promised that.
Archival: God bless you, and go in His peace.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: Now with the battle lines clearly drawn, it was time for Sal and Trav to negotiate a deal. Time to compromise. Time to stand firm in the face of overwhelming opposition. Time to test Sal's promise.
Sal DiMasi: That's right. That's exactly right and I told them time and time again, every meeting we had, that I would keep that promise.
MUSIC: Out
Archival: Have all members voted who wish to do so? Time for voting has expired. The clerk will display the tally.
NARRATION: It's now mid-November, 2005. The House and Senate, led by Sal and Trav, have both moved ahead and passed their own -- very different -- healthcare bills. The governor, in case you're wondering, is basically on the sidelines for now, and the action moves to the conference committee: a small group of House and Senate members -- to see if they can make any progress on reconciling the two bills. One staffer on that committee told me that in the old days they would literally cut up the text of each bill with scissors and then tape together a final version made from bits and pieces of each. By 2005 that all happened on a computer, but it was still painstaking work.
Ron Mariano: We would meet Tuesdays and Thursdays. Minimum of two hours.
NARRATION: Ron Mariano was one of the House members on the committee, and as I record this he is the current House Speaker. In fact, I interviewed him in Sal's old office, at Sal's old desk. So Mariano has been around many high stakes negotiations. But none quite like this – because the House and Senate bills were so different.
Ron Mariano: The progress was agonizingly slow. And I remember coming in here one day and throwing my notebook into this table from the doorway. And saying, I'm done. I'm done. I said, I can't deal with these people anymore. Sal’s yelling at me in Italian about the pazienza. Have patience, have patience.
NARRATION: Several people actually quoted this exact line from Sal -- it was a favorite of his.
Emily Sherwood: Avviata pazienza.
Christie Hager: Have patience. Have patience.
Ron Mariano: I said, “You have patience. I'm not.” So he gave me a Diet Coke and I sat here for a while and then I went back the next Thursday. But it was that frustrating.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Sal and Trav were now locked in a game of chicken.
They were two cars barreling towards each other in the same lane, both refusing to swerve. Because as I've said again and again, doing nothing meant losing a billion dollars in federal funding. That was the head-on collision. Everyone loses. To avert that collision, someone would have to swerve. But so far, Sal was content to let everyone sweat a bit. To his staff he said "have patience." To the press, he said nothing.
Sal DiMasi: Because the silence will be deafening.
NARRATION: The Bush administration had set a deadline of July 1st, 2006 in order for the state to keep their special pot of federal money. That was when the ticking time bomb would detonate and potentially bring down the state's most vulnerable hospitals. But July 2006 was the deadline for having the new policy up and running. According to experts, the bill would need to be passed six months before that if they were going to have any shot of meeting the deadline.
Archival: There is widespread agreement on Beacon Hill these days about one thing: something has to be done about health insurance.
NARRATION: Yet December came and went with no deal. January came and went with no deal. And Sal kept to his same line.
Sal DiMasi: Abbi pazienza. And what that means is if you wait, right, things will happen for the better, just wait.
NARRATION: Just wait. Something will happen. And it did.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: As best I can tell, the shift came in February 2006.
Everyone was in a conference meeting at the State House, one of those agonizing two hour cut and paste sessions. Sal and Trav were there in person, along with their conferees, and on this day they had dialed in a bureaucrat in DC to talk through some details of the bill.
Ron Mariano: And Sal's talking to the intercom.
NARRATION: Again, Ron Mariano.
Ron Mariano: And no one else is listening to him. And he's arguing with someone from Washington. I forget even what it was. And I'm thinking to myself, no one is paying attention.
NARRATION: Mariano remembers looking around the table at an almost comic scene. One member was tediously unwrapping a hard candy using just one hand. Another member who was hard of hearing, kept asking again and again to repeat something they missed. And then Trav himself leaning back in his chair, filing his nails while Sal shouted at the speakerphone. Mariano thought to himself: this is a waste of time.
Ron Mariano: Finally, it ended and we're breaking up and people are walking out, and I was the furthest away from the doorway. And I was walking out, Trav grabbed my jacket and he said, “Hey, what did you think of that?”
And I said, “I said, it was like watching a sitcom.” And he says, “Yeah, I know, I know, I know.” He says, “You're gonna do me a favor.” I said, “What?” He says, “You're gonna get the guy from the North End to talk to the guy from East Boston.”
NARRATION: The guy from the North End was Sal of course, and the guy from East Boston was Travaglini himself. Trav was asking Mariano to broker a meeting, one on one.
Ron Mariano: I said, “Oh.” I said, “I think I can do that.”
NARRATION: Mariano asked for a time and place. Travaglini said Friday, 10 AM, the Speaker's Office. Trav would come across the hall to Sal.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Friday at 10 AM sharp, President Travaglini came bounding into the Speaker's grand but kind of shabby office.
Ron Mariano: He's got a track suit on and a baseball hat, throws his jacket in the corner, comes over to the table. And he says, “Let's go to work.”
NARRATION: But in the days leading up to that meeting, Mariano had gathered a little intel on Trav, and what Trav really wanted out of this bill. It had to do with hospitals.
I know I haven't talked about the hospitals in a while, but they had remained very much involved, because they had a tremendous amount at stake. The whole idea, remember, was to take money that was going directly to the hospitals to help cover care for the uninsured, and instead use it to get those people insured. Now in theory this change could work out fine for the hospitals. All those people who had been getting free care, would now have insurance that paid for their care. So the money could still find its way to the hospital. But there were also a lot of ways it could work out poorly, especially in the short term.
What had finally clicked for Mariano, was that many of the biggest hospitals in the state were in and around Trav’s district. They were his constituents, and he had to look out for them in this.
Ron Mariano: I said, “I think we can do that.”
NARRATION: What Sal told me, is that once they started adding some additional state money into their bill to support the hospitals, Trav became more open to some kind of employer mandate.
Bob Travaglini: And I was okay with that. As long as it was balanced, it had to be balanced.
NARRATION: The mandate could not be as harsh as Sal had wanted, but it could be something.
Bob Travaglini: You don't have to omit anything in its entirety. Let's see if we can, you know, represent everything in balance.
NARRATION: So they scrapped the payroll tax, which businesses hated, and changed it to a simple penalty companies would have to pay for each uninsured worker. I know that sounds like pure semantics, but for employers it did make a difference to tie the payment to the number of uninsured workers, rather than the total payroll. In any case, this wasn't what any of the players would have chosen coming in, but a flat employer penalty might just be the thing everyone could live with.
And so ultimately, the fate of the bill came down to a single number. How much would that penalty be? Sal started at $600. So if you employed 100 people and offered no insurance to those people, you'd pay the state $60,000 a year. Real money. To give you a sense of how far apart they started -- a group of business leaders suggested a penalty of $62. To Sal that was a joke, a slap on the wrist.
Bob Travaglini: We couldn't reach consensus.
NARRATION: Again, President Travaglini, who was still more inclined to agree with the business community on this issue.
Bob Travaglini: We had, you know, a hard conversation and then we just went silent on each other. And this is what happens when you get to the one yard line.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: It was now the end of February. They had a framework for a deal, but once again they were stuck.
Bob Travaglini: So I said, let me, let me send a jolt.
NARRATION: Now it was Trav's turn to play mind games.
Bob Travaglini: So we gave them a jolt.
NARRATION: On February 24th, a Friday, he declared to the press that sweeping health reform was basically dead. He was done.
Bob Travaglini: Let me, lemme see if I can shake them up.
MUSIC: Post
NARRATION: Travaglini's jolt radiated out in every direction. Insurers, hospitals, activists, business leaders, Kennedy, Romney, the Bush administration -- everyone felt it. The headline in the Globe that weekend read: "Hopes fade on reforms in healthcare." And it did shake things up.
Pretty soon, Mitt Romney showed up at Sal's house in the North End in person. No one was home, so the governor taped a message to the front door, urging him to compromise. Sal called up his faith leader allies, and asked them to hold a press conference in front of Trav's office. It was maximum pressure, all around.
That same week notices went out to dozens of hospitals around the state saying that their federal funding would be cut starting July 1st. 6 million dollars from Baystate Medical Center, 10 million from Mass General, 62 million for Boston Medical Center. It was a head-on car crash in slow motion, and still, neither Sal nor Trav would bend.
MUSIC: Out
Sal DiMasi: Kennedy makes the call to me, that famous call.
NARRATION: Ted Kennedy was of course monitoring the situation closely, and anxiously. Typically he did not insert himself into state politics. He had his sandbox, they had theirs, but this would have to be an exception. He picked up the phone.
Sal DiMasi: And he said to me, “You need to back off.”
NARRATION: Kennedy, I should say, had supported Sal's bill, and the employer mandate. But at this point he was desperate to see something get passed, even if it wasn't as comprehensive as both he and Sal wanted.
Sal DiMasi: And I said, "Ted, how long have you been, waiting to have comprehensive healthcare reform in your career?"
He says, "My entire career, Sal. This is the only opportunity we have.” He paused for a long time and he said, "I trust you, Sal. Do what you have to do."
Bob Travaglini: Ted Kennedy—I never tell this story.
NARRATION: Trav got the call too.
Bob Travaglini: He called the car, my daughter Taylor was riding shotgun with me and the gentleman on the phone said, “Hi, this is Ted Kennedy, is your dad there?” And she said, “Nice try, Uncle Frank.” And she hangs up the phone figuring it was one of my friends trying to be funny with her and give her a hard time.
I said, “Taylor, who was that?” She said, “Dad, that was Uncle Frank making believe he's Senator Kennedy.” I said, “No, that was probably Senator Kennedy. Gimme the phone.” I called him back. He's laughing. He's laughing his ass off. He said, “I've been in this business 35 years. Nobody ever hung up the phone on me. I want to meet that young lady.”
NARRATION: Then Kennedy got serious. Wherever you're going, turn around; I need you to get back to the State House, get back in the room with Sal. Kennedy had been in their shoes before and he had let the moment pass. Now, he pleaded:
Bob Travaglini: We're close. We're so close. We're so close. Come on. He said, “Tell me you're gonna do it.” I said, “I'll do it.” He said, “That's all I need to hear.”
MUSIC: Transition
NARRATION: In the first days of March 2006, there were signs of new life. Sal and Trav met at their usual Italian restaurant, the one where they never even saw the menu. It was actually their wives -- Debbie and Kelly -- who conspired to set it up. As Sal's wife told me: the men were acting like boys, and someone had to tell them to 'knock it off.'
Sal DiMasi: And as good husbands, we did what our wives told us to do.
Bob Travaglini: Scolded, taken to the woodshed and then to dinner.
Sal DiMasi: That's true.
NARRATION: Finally, the guy from East Boston and the guy from the North End were talking. So now there was just one final piece they needed to get in the room with them. Someone who could speak for the business community itself, who could make that final deal with authority. Someone named Jack Connors.
MUSIC: Out
Jack Connors: So my name is Jack Connors, and back in the day I was the, uh, CEO of Hill Holliday Advertising in Boston.
NARRATION: Longtime listeners may remember that name and voice from Season 2, because among many other things, Jack Connors ran the advertising company that did all the TV ads for the state lottery. Jack passed away a few months after our interview, but that story we told about his advertising career doesn't even begin to capture his stature in this town.
Bob Travaglini: Jack was ever present. He was huge.
NARRATION: Because besides founding one of the biggest ad firms in the city, Jack Connors was on the boards of several major universities including Harvard Medical School, and he chaired the board of the biggest hospital system in the state. He was someone who bridged the worlds of politics and business.
Bob Travaglini: He could pick up a phone and make things happen in a matter of minutes.
Ian Coss: Yeah.
Bob Travaglini: He was a power player.
Jack Connors: No, no, no. The power was never in my hands.
NARRATION: And like the best power players, Jack wasn't flashy about it. In our conversation, he always played that part down.
Jack Connors: I was a supplicant. But I was never important, except in my own mind.
NARRATION: Jack Connors had come home from a golf trip to find that scary headline -- "Hopes fade on reforms in healthcare", staring at him on page A1 of the Boston Globe. He had gotten the jolt, and in that moment he realized that his fellow business leaders, in fighting against the employer mandate, they'd gone too hard. They had backed Sal into a corner and now everyone needed to lighten up.
So Jack called the Speaker's office and asked for 15 minutes with Sal, because he was the kind of person who could do that. Then he called up the media library at his ad firm and requested a film clip. Some accounts say it was a VHS tape, some say it was a DVD, but everyone agrees on the movie:
Sal DiMasi: Jack came in and he played “Animal House.”
NARRATION: "Animal House"
Archival: What? Over? Did you say over? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor?
NARRATION: Specifically the scene where John Belushi rallies the downcast, misfit members of Delta House.
Sal DiMasi: And he said, "It ain't over until we say it's over."
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Jack and Sal had a good laugh, then got to business. The two sides had been stuck on the exact number to charge employers for every worker they did not insure. Sal wanted $600 a head. That group of business leaders had countered with $62 a head. But that day Jack indicated: if you can budge, we can budge.
And so in a story of many many meetings, we now arrive at the final meeting: the morning of Friday, March 3rd. Some say it was in the Speaker's Office, some say it was the Senate President's Office. But like I said, the two are not far apart at all. So it would all come down to this: Sal, Trav, Jack, and their advisors in a room.
MUSIC: Out
John McDonough: And we had all heard that it was happening.
NARRATION: John McDonough, the healthcare activist, was not in the room, but he was there at the State House. He described it like a papal conclave, with everyone waiting outside the door to see what color smoke came out of the chimney.
John McDonough: So there's about a hundred people on the third floor of the State House, just meandering around. Did you hear anything? Did you hear anything?
NARRATION: While, inside the room, the leaders and their staff got down to brass tacks: the employer penalty. Starting with Sal's original figure: 600 dollars.
Christie Hager: So it came down from there.
NARRATION: Again, Christie Hager, Sal's health advisor.
Christie Hager: And as the discussions went on, it was like, 500? No, 499. 498? No.
NARRATION: After months of saying 'have patience, have patience', Sal was now negotiating.
Christie Hager: But, it was never just give that up, would you? It was more, let's get to yes on this.
Ian Coss: Yeah.
Christie Hager: And that was expected and asked of everybody.
NARRATION: So at the same time Sal was inching down, Trav and Jack were inching up on what they could accept. Someone told me there was a feeling of reverence in the room as the two sides finally converged on a single number.
Christie Hager: 295 was the number.
NARRATION: A 295 dollar penalty, per employee. Right in the middle.
John McDonough: And then, you know, the metaphorical cloud of white smoke came out of the office and there was a deal. That was the end of the game.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: Ted’s brother John F. Kennedy had an old saying he liked to quote. It goes: "Victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan." He said that famously in 1961, right after the failure of the Bay of Pigs invasion. So Kennedy was living the defeat side, isolated, when no one wanted to take ownership of what had happened. The 2006 Massachusetts healthcare reform lives on the other side of that ledger.
It was stunning to me, how when I started researching the topic, I would talk to someone close to the story, who would give me a whole list of who I should talk to -- the people who were really key to making it all happen. Then I would get on the phone with someone else and get a totally different list. It became almost comical. It was all about the faith leaders; or no, it was all about the business leaders. It was all about the committee staff. No, it was all about the Blue Cross Blue Shield Foundation. It was all about the governor, or all about the legislature. It was Jack Connors, it was John McDonough, it was Ted Kennedy, it was Sal and Trav's wives. I've never covered an event that so many people are eager to take credit for. And the simple truth of it, is that they are all right.
That was the difference between 1988 and 2006. The Dukakis bill did in fact come down to the will and influence of one man. That is why it failed.
MUSIC: Out
NARRATION: But in a way, that John F. Kennedy quote is backwards in this case. It's not that people rush to take credit because the bill is seen as a victory. The bill was a victory because so many people could take credit for it.
MUSIC: Enter
NARRATION: A few weeks after the deal was announced, almost every person I've interviewed converged for the signing ceremony. It was supposed to be a celebration of compromise, bipartisanship, collaboration.
Archival: The bill makes health insurance available to virtually every Massachusetts resident…
NARRATION: But under the surface, the Romneycare alliance was already starting to fray, starting with Mitt Romney himself.
Ron Mariano: As we're walking off the stage, Sal reaches into his suit coat pocket, and he pulls out four or five vetoes. He says, “The governor gave me these on the way in.” And I said, “You’re shittin’ me.”
NARRATION: That's next time.
Archival: So much for bipartisan back-patting. It's already back to politics as usual.
MUSIC: Theme
CREDITS
The Big Dig is produced by Isabel Hibbard and myself, Ian Coss. It’s edited by Lacy Roberts. The editorial supervisor is Azita Ghahramani with support from Ryan Alderman. And the Executive Producer is Devin Maverick Robins.
As the title of this episode suggests, there are so many more people who are part of this story, but who you do not hear. I spoke with several of them, and so want to give a special thanks to Patricia Walrath, Jeffrey Sanchez, John Sasso, Peter Meade, Tom Glynn, Andrew Dreyfus, Michael Widmer, Barbara Anthony, David Nexon, Jonah Pesner, and Cheri Andes. All of you helped me understand this story.
Archival sound came from, among other places: Boston City TV, Bethel African Episcopal Church, and the House Broadcast Services and State Library of Massachusetts.
The artwork is by Bill Miller. Our closing song is “Things Will Be Different,” by The Shods. The Big Dig is a production of GBH News and distributed by PRX.