There’s no question that ousted Department of Children and Families Commissioner Olga Roche made some mistakes, chief among them was telling a legislative committee that she was certain there were no more “Jeremiah Oliver cases” out there— that all children under DCF care had been accounted for.
There’s no way she could know that for certain, so saying it made her sound naïve, not a quality you want in your DCF commissioner. She didn’t inspire confidence, which made her leadership shaky, and the governor was right to accept her resignation.
But the governor is right about something else too, the failures and tragedies within the department that have been laid at Roche’s feet are not her doing, they are the doings of incompetent and abusive parents and guardians of children who exercise the right to procreate but have no clue what to do next.
Just a quick Google search took me to a string of Massachusetts DSS and DCF commissioners who lost their jobs over child abuse cases that occurred on their watches. In each case, the blame fell squarely on the shoulders of whichever commissioner was at the helm at the time, regardless of who actually committed the crime.
Gerald Robinson took the fall in 1992 over the Mikey Sanborn case, a young boy who was senselessly ripped from the care of his foster parents and returned to a father who had burned him with scalding water.
Linda Carlisle came next, promising a “complete overhaul of the system” and of course the omnipresent promise of lower caseloads for social workers. She departed in the wake of the Everett “House of Horrors—” a squalid home where five half-naked children lurked among piles of garbage and animal feces.
Then there was the earnest and affable Harry Spence who took a job he didn’t need because he sincerely felt he could make a difference. He was forced to resign after a brain-damaged child who was about to be taken off life support suddenly started to speak. It was as if he had tried to pull the plug himself. Spence resisted stepping down but Governor Deval Patrick forced his hand.
And now Olga Roche leaves with the blood of three children on her record, 5-year-old Jeremiah Oliver who may have been murdered and then stuffed in a suitcase and dumped by the side of the road, and two babies who died under suspicious circumstances in their homes.
In one case, Grafton police faxed a 51A (report of suspected child abuse) to DCF but did not follow up with a phone call. Someone at DCF had to have read that fax, and did nothing. That, too, was Olga Roche’s fault, at least according to know-it-alls like House Speaker Bob DeLeo.
I can say with virtual certainty that something horrible is going to happen under interim DCF Commissioner Erin Devaney’s tenure, too –- even though she is going to “overhaul the department and make sure social workers get fewer caseloads.” That ought to do it, right Mr. Speaker?
Emily Rooney is the host of Greater Boston.