Last week, we talked about the Boston Globe Spotlight team’s investigation into Regal Care, a nursing home chain that rapidly expanded after the pandemic, taking over some Massachusetts nursing homes that saw patient care decline. Now, Massachusetts regulators are moving to revoke all of Regal Care’s nursing home licenses. Regal Care is challenging the action, and for now, its 12 Massachusetts homes remain open, but with weekly monitoring from the Department of Public Health. Globe reporter Kay Lazar joins GBH’s All Things Considered host Arun Rath to explain what the state’s action means for residents, families, and nursing home oversight in Massachusetts. What follows is a lightly edited transcript of their conversation.
Arun Rath: Now, I didn’t think it would be quite this soon, but obviously there’s been a big development. Now, when we spoke last week, we talked about the Department of Public Health’s responses to problems at Regal Care homes. Basically, they would pay a fine and move on. So, my first question is actually, why revoke all the licenses now? I mean, it’s hard not to imagine the Spotlight reporting and public attention played a role.
Kay Lazar: Yes, apparently it did. We were as surprised as I think a lot of people when we got the notice late Tuesday. What the department said, and what the commissioner said, is that [until] the Spotlight story, they had not realized that Eli Mirlis, who is the chief executive of Regal Care, had essentially lied on all of his applications for nursing home licenses here. He had checked a box saying he had never had a professional license revoked and that just was not true.
The Spotlight investigation showed that in New Jersey, a number of years ago, authorities there had revoked his license to be a nursing home administrator because he lied on an application about taking education credits that were required to have that license — to renew it. So, that was cited by the commissioner here as one reason for moving to revoke the company’s licenses here. In addition, the company, Regal Care, recently settled with the U.S. Attorney here, a $1 million settlement for Medicare and Medicaid fraud in some of his nursing homes. Additionally, the Department of Public Health said they conducted a complete review of the quality and safety in their homes and had found them lacking.
Rath: So, the nursing home licenses were revoked by the DPH, but that is being appealed. Where does that leave things now with these homes in question?
Lazar: Right. So they haven’t — they’re asking them to be revoked. It will now go to an administrative law judge. It’s sort of like a parallel thing to a court, and they will essentially fight it out. But what it does now for families and residents is, what the status says is, they’re not closing these facilities. People still will remain in them.
What it means is that they will have surveyors, or inspectors from the health department in these nursing homes at least once a week to monitor things: to take a walk around and take a look and see if the care, the quality and the safety is up to snuff and to keep a very watchful eye about what is really going on there because, as our reporting had indicated, there were numerous, numerous problems in a number of these homes where people were.
There were medication errors. They were running out of basic supplies, sometimes bread, milk, paper towels, just basic things to keep the place open. There were call lights that were not being answered. People were sitting in soiled clothing for hours. The care was not particularly good in a number of these places.
Rath: And what would happen if they find violations?
Lazar: So, that they would obviously order them to correct them and they would face further fines. Obviously, if you have deficiencies — that’s the official term — they find deficiencies and then you would pay a fine. Although, we have seen the track record with this company that the fines don’t seem to mean a whole lot, that they’ve been fined repeatedly.
And in some cases, they’ve actually had to close their doors to new patients, new residents, while they corrected problems, if they were very serious. That’s termed immediate jeopardy and that’s happened in a few of those cases. They just reopen again and keep going. So hopefully, it is different now when the state’s saying that they are keeping a much closer eye.
Rath: Regal Care is the one that we’ve talked about. But the Spotlight investigation, you found that nine out-of-state companies with questionable records now own one in five Massachusetts nursing homes. Does this latest development signal any kind of a shift in how the state might be regulating nursing homes going forward?
Lazar: One would certainly hope so. That is with what the Department of Public Health and the commissioner have vowed in the past week or two that they are definitely going to be taking a much closer look at companies.
In fact, the State Public Health Council, which is an appointed board of experts, met this week to actually adopt tighter regulations that have been in the works for nearly two years now. At that meeting, the commissioner made very strong statements that they’re putting nursing home companies on notice, that they will be taking a much closer look now at operations, particularly staffing levels, which have been problematic.
Rath: Finally, just looking at this again broadly, does it seem like the existing Department of Public Health has the tools that they need to fix this problem?
Lazar: Certainly, on paper they do. Absolutely. They have now all kinds of new regulations. One would argue even the older regulations had the tools because it said you should be looking at out-of-state track records and in-state track records. So on paper, for sure. I think the question is, you know, we have asked, do you have enough staffing to do all this background checking and checking on these nursing homes? And the commissioner did tell us, “Yes.”
He thought they had sufficient staffing, but if he needed more, he would ask. I think time will tell. I mean, if there’s the will and the passion to do this, I think they do. Certainly, legally, they have all the tools they need now.
Rath: But I mean, not to just like make the point too finely, they did miss how Mirlis got his licenses revoked in 2018 and lied about that on his Massachusetts applications.
Lazar: They did. They absolutely did, and it’s hard to know their point. When we interviewed the commissioner with a sit-down in September, they did not have the authority to consider out-of-state track records. The new regulations did clearly say it had the authority to check out-of-state track record as it applied to their nursing homes out of state. So one would think that they have the tools to see this and they just somehow didn’t check.