The Four Biggest Best Picture Oscar Upsets, Statistically Speaking
Matt Stiles and Elise Hu
Saturday, February 23, 2013 at 1:56 PM
Comments
Font size: A | A | A | A

David Putnam, producer of <em>Chariots of Fire</em>, holds up his Oscar after the movie won best picture in 1982.

David Putnam, producer of Chariots of Fire, holds up his Oscar after the movie won best picture in 1982.

AP


As the Directors and Producers Guild Awards go, so does the Academy. At least most of the time.

Mel Gibson, center, stars in Paramount Pictures' <em>Braveheart</em>.

Mel Gibson, center, stars in Paramount Pictures' Braveheart.

Andrew Cooper / AP

Producers and cast celebrate after winning best picture for <em>Shakespeare in Love</em> during the 71st Annual Academy Awards.

Producers and cast celebrate after winning best picture for Shakespeare in Love during the 71st Annual Academy Awards.

Dave Caulkin / AP

The cast of <em>Crash</em> celebrates after its surprise upset of <em>Brokeback Mountain</em> for best picture, at the 78th Academy Awards in 2006.

The cast of Crash celebrates after its surprise upset of Brokeback Mountain for best picture, at the 78th Academy Awards in 2006.

Mark J. Terrill / AP

By the time the curtains rise on the Academy Awards ceremony each year, Oscar-watching prognosticators are already reasonably sure which films are going to take home top prizes.

Their predictions are mostly driven by frenzied intra-industry campaigning, prolific press coverage and the closest approximation of Oscar "polls" — the winners of the dozens of awards that precede the Oscars each year. But of the 16 preceding awards analyzed by The New York Times' political statistician Nate Silver, only two — the Directors Guild Awards and the Producers Guild Awards — have a greater than 50 percent success rate in predicting eventual Oscar winners. (The Directors Guild aligns with Oscar eight out of 10 times.) "Directors and producers are the movers and shakers in Hollywood, and any evidence about their opinions ought to count for a lot," Silver writes.

And their guilds are packed with Academy voters, so it makes sense that major category winners tend to match. In fact, when we analyzed the data, only four times since the Directors and Producers Guild Awards have existed have their top film picks of the year awards not overlapped with the Academy's best picture winner.

That kind of track record makes for stunning upsets on Oscar night.

With the help of film critic Chris Vognar of The Dallas Morning News, we took a look back at the biggest upsets, or to put a more positive spin on it, biggest surprise wins in the best picture category:

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.


Filed in:


Also in Arts & Life  

News updates from WGBH

See a sample »

   


rss icon
Follow

WGBH News Special Coverage: ELECTION 2012 from NPR

WGBH Spring Auction 2013


Vehicle donation (June 2012) 89.7

News Categories